mercedes benz vs bmw

[chenx15]

Hi everyone! i am a big japanese car fan specially Honda but going through this forum i have seen a lot of european car following. I am not a big car nut and i have no clue when it comes to car i just love honda.

can people please enlighten me about mercedes benz and bmw. can i ask which one is better without being politcaly incorrect?

enlightenment will be greatly appreciated i am ignorant so please consider this as a MB vs BMW for a dummy.

thanks guys and gals!

[JPersat]

IMHO, I really like MB alot better, they just look better, and seem to hold their value better

[xblk33360]

there really isn't which one's better.
although both Mercedes and BMW are german car companies that produce luxury cars, and they have many models are are in direct competition with each other, they are actually quite different.

If you are looking for a car the feels very luxurious, a car that can deliver very smooth ride, while also having an engine that delivers crazy amount of RAW power, Mercedes is the way to go.

If you want a car that has less of the luxury feel, but a car that feels much more balanced, and a car that handles very well, and although may NOT be EXTREMELY fast from 0-60 but handles very well around the corners, BMW is the way to go.

Obviously, both of the above are just generalizations of the more expensive cars that the companies offer (ie. S-class, AMG line up, ///M line up, etc.).

For the lower priced mercedes/bmw, they still have variations, but are in more of direct competition with each other, and it really depends on just personal preference.

[boa2]

Originally Posted by xblk33360

there really isn't which one's better.
although both Mercedes and BMW are german car companies that produce luxury cars, and they have many models are are in direct competition with each other, they are actually quite different.

If you are looking for a car the feels very luxurious, a car that can deliver very smooth ride, while also having an engine that delivers crazy amount of RAW power, Mercedes is the way to go.

If you want a car that has less of the luxury feel, but a car that feels much more balanced, and a car that handles very well, and although may NOT be EXTREMELY fast from 0-60 but handles very well around the corners, BMW is the way to go.

Obviously, both of the above are just generalizations of the more expensive cars that the companies offer (ie. S-class, AMG line up, ///M line up, etc.).

For the lower priced mercedes/bmw, they still have variations, but are in more of direct competition with each other, and it really depends on just personal preference.

Couldn't have said it better.

You must drive both to get a sense of how they feel/handle...completely different approach. I prefer the handling of BMW, and the comfort of the MB. Therefore, I drive an Audi, which for me is the perfect balance of the two, and absent the characteristics of either MB or BMW that I dislike.

[GBJIV]

Originally Posted by boa2

Couldn't have said it better.

You must drive both to get a sense of how they feel/handle...completely different approach. I prefer the handling of BMW, and the comfort of the MB. Therefore, I drive an Audi, which for me is the perfect balance of the two, and absent the characteristics of either MB or BMW that I dislike.

I like that Audi comparison... Very interesting. The new Q5 is very cool car.

[Bisquitlips]

So why are we discussing this again when you have this to look at?



And this one??



Nothing like having two of everything!

[JJ Irani]

WOW!! Are those both yours, Richard??

[Bisquitlips]

Originally Posted by JJ Irani

WOW!! Are those both yours, Richard??

Had them both at one time JJ. Now only have the Z4.

[mretzloff]

Originally Posted by chenx15

can people please enlighten me about mercedes benz and bmw. can i ask which one is better without being politcaly incorrect?

How can you be politically incorrect about cars?

I like MB better. I think BMWs look too sporty for a luxury car. My favorite is probably the S-class.

[AIKO]

I am also a Japanese car fan-Acura and Honda. I live in SC, home of North America BMW. Both are different in my eyes-MB more luxery and BMW more performance oriented.

[xblk33360]

and as far as japanese cars go, i have 3 letters. G T R. haha

[mretzloff]

Originally Posted by AIKO

I am also a Japanese car fan-Acura and Honda. I live in SC, home of North America BMW. Both are different in my eyes-MB more luxery and BMW more performance oriented.

Have you toured the factory? I did and thought it was interesting.

They have pictures of all the BMW factories in the world on a wall. It was hilarious how the tour guide just "skipped" over the ones in Egypt, India, etc.

[AIKO]

Originally Posted by mretzloff

Have you toured the factory? I did and thought it was interesting.

They have pictures of all the BMW factories in the world on a wall. It was hilarious how the tour guide just "skipped" over the ones in Egypt, India, etc.

I have not, three of my neighbors have (here in SC, there is also a Germany pickup where they will ship your car back home). The process is order direct from the factory. Arrive in the afternoon-they put you up in a nice hotel for the evening and provide dinner for 2 at a nice restaurant (wine included). There is a half day driving class with on road and track driving with an instructor on one of their cars (not yours). Then, they spend 2 hours with you delivering your car-set up inside in a dramatic presentation platform and go over all the features. Leave late afternoon. I "think" it is about $1200. Sounds cool.

[GrandDaddy]

Chen, you don't look old enough to be driving a Mercedes. Even I don't feel that old to drive one (I drive an M3). Just my opinion, MB=for old people. And, as soon as you buy a Mercedes and start driving it, you will look 10-15 years older. Just a short MB true story: My friend wanted one so bad so he told his wife either she lets him get a Mercedes with four wheels or he will get a Mercedes with two legs. He is now driving a Mercedes with four wheels.

[mretzloff]

Originally Posted by AIKO

I have not, three of my neighbors have (here in SC, there is also a Germany pickup where they will ship your car back home). The process is order direct from the factory. Arrive in the afternoon-they put you up in a nice hotel for the evening and provide dinner for 2 at a nice restaurant (wine included). There is a half day driving class with on road and track driving with an instructor on one of their cars (not yours). Then, they spend 2 hours with you delivering your car-set up inside in a dramatic presentation platform and go over all the features. Leave late afternoon. I "think" it is about $1200. Sounds cool.

A man and woman on the tour I was on did that. I think it's great to take the time to know what you're driving.

[ROLEX MAN]

I've had both, currently still have BMW, would lean towards Mercedes for the next one!

I find Mercedes slightly better build quality and quieter to drive (Luxury), BMW is more sporty!

[CharlieG]

I too have owned both. Current rides are X5 and M3. I prefer the BMW's. Overall, I like the sportier feel and handling characteristics of the BMW's.

[clew84]

Originally Posted by CharlieG

I too have owned both. Current rides are X5 and M3. I prefer the BMW's. Overall, I like the sportier feel and handling characteristics of the BMW's.

+1. BMWs just handle extremely well and I like their look a little better - more sporty than luxury.

[drtooth73]

Originally Posted by CharlieG

I too have owned both. Current rides are X5 and M3. I prefer the BMW's. Overall, I like the sportier feel and handling characteristics of the BMW's.

Nice.
I have a 5 series and wife has X3.

[Drumr]

BMW is a drivers car and Mercedes is a luxury car. At least in the lower end this hold true... of course when you get into the 7 series and the S class they're both performance as well as luxury but thats besides the point. A Mercedes is effortless to drive, and depending on the configuration, they're quick. A 3 series is easy but you know alot more by feel what is going on.

But what do i know... I drive a VW! :-D

[xblk33360]

Originally Posted by Drumr

BMW is a drivers car and Mercedes is a luxury car. At least in the lower end this hold true... of course when you get into the 7 series and the S class they're both performance as well as luxury but thats besides the point. A Mercedes is effortless to drive, and depending on the configuration, they're quick. A 3 series is easy but you know alot more by feel what is going on.

But what do i know... I drive a VW! :-D

well VW group. they are part of Porsche. and you know, as far as german cars go, there's nothing like a P car :D

[swatty]

Have to agree wil all the comments so far. I work with both brands mentioned each day (servicing, mechanical repairs) . Its really a matter of personal preference as to which one to drive. I prefer Mercedes for everyday driving, but you can't beat an M3 on the track . I suppose european cars just seem to have more character than Japanese cars. Having said that , a Japanese car will suit most peoples requirements for every day driving .

[gmtobsessed]

I've owned BMW once in the past, but the fast falling resale value make
me regret. Other than that, its fantastic to drive, IMO it have better grip
(320i) compare to Merc C200K.
But I prefer the look of Mercedes in general

[2careless]

We own both (me MB B200 turbo, wife BMW 325i). Both are ~7.5s from 0-100, but the BMW engine just sounds so much nicer and the ride is perfect. However, BMW hasn't got the model diversity compared to MB. And yes, I've been called grandpa by my German friends

[betrezra]

BENZ +1 A gentleman's car.

[TswaneNguni]

Always,always BMW !!

2001 E320 needed a new engine at 28000km.New bottom end needed .Bad attitude from Mercedes.Never ,never,never again !!

Wife had a 1999 328i ....sold at 165000km .... not a single problem !!

I have a 330d auto 2003 .... 130000km ... perfect !! Great car,not a single problem ever !!

Recently bought another one... a late 2004 330i with only 20300km on the clock,at rockbottom recession pricing. Their are some great deals to be found !!!

So,I now have two E46 BMWs and couldnt be happier.Great cars,low purchase pricing and very low insurance cost.

[i2onnel]

Audi/BMW > Benz

[chenx15]

is it worth buying brand new when it comes to these type of cars or preowned will be good enough. like rolex

[mretzloff]

Originally Posted by chenx15

is it worth buying brand new when it comes to these type of cars or preowned will be good enough. like rolex

It's worth it not to buy them. Think about...by the time you sell it, it'll be worth next to nothing.

[Cato]

Honda has treated me very well. I bought a new 1997 Honda Prelude and am still driving it today. It has 160,000 miles and I have had ZERO problems. It drives like the day I bought it (as far as I can remember :) ).

My next vehicle will be something more interesting though.