Rolex Explorer II Trade

[brochris]

Hello Everyone, I am fairly new to this forum but I am in desperate need of help. I have a trade that I am seriously considering and just wanted to get some opinions. I have an Omega Seamaster Planet Ocean XL 45mm version and a Girard Perregaux 1945 Vintage Ref. 2583 that I am thinking about trading for a Rolex Explorer II (White Dial) 2001 Model. I love the Omega but it is just a little too large for my wrists. The 42mm fits perfectly and the GP is a beautiful watch but the resale is horrible; however, I am a little hesitant on giving up the GP just because of the movement; the brands history and the fact that in the "watch world" it is a highly respected brand. Value wise, it seems to be a pretty even trade. The seller is selling the Explorer for about $4000 and he values the Omega at about $2500 and the GP at $1500. Please let me know your thoughts.

[tfduff723]

Hi & welcome to TRF

I have the same model Exp II (1999 A serial white dial). It is a great watch in every way, one of my favorites and I don't think you would be disappointed. There are many, many posts here on TRF regarding the Explorer II. I would suggest using the search function - you will find more info (& great pics) than you will have time to read.

Personally, I would go for the Exp II if the watch is in good shape with box, papers, etc... The $4K value seems in the window for what an Exp II from that time frame would sell for here on TRF.

I am not too familiar with the trade value on your Omega & GP. However, the Rolex sport models do tend to hold their value far better than just about any brand including Omega. Plus the Exp II 16570 is now a discontinued model. I used to own a GP but sold it to fund an IWC which I later sold to fund a Rolex GMT II 16710. The GMT is here to stay and I have never really missed the GP.

There are many others here on TRF that can likely weigh in.

Good luck

[Brushpup]

I know nothing about the GP, so my advice may be worthless. If the Rolex is in good conditiin and the others arent sentimental, I say go for it.

[slcbbrown]

For me, the ExpII is a great choice. I bought one of the black face versions for each of two of my sons. I´m always impressed with the ünder-the-radar look and toughness. I´d trade the Omega in a minute, but I´m not so sure about the value of $2,500. As to the GP, it would make a great dress model to go with your ExpII. $1,500 seems a bit low. What did you pay for it?

[brochris]

Well, I got a heck of a deal on the GP. I paid $1,300 without boxes and papers. For some reason or another the GP's, well at least that model, is not in high demand at all and as a result suffer from very low resale values.

[nick c]

Welcome and good luck

[Time Exposure]

Rolex Forum: "Get the Rolex."
Omega Forum: "Keep the Omega."
GP forum: "Hello? Anybody here?"
:)

[Brushpup]

Originally Posted by Time Exposure

Rolex Forum: "Get the Rolex."
Omega Forum: "Keep the Omega."
GP forum: "Hello? Anybody here?"
:)

[Maxfli]

Originally Posted by brochris

The seller is selling the Explorer for about $4000 and he values the Omega at about $2500 and the GP at $1500. Please let me know your thoughts.

The question is, how do you value these watches? Have you done your homework and searched this and other forums for comp sales? If I were you, I'd do that first before entering into a deal.

[Hairdude1]

Best of luck with your search!

[sea-dweller]

Good luck, I can say that the Exp II is a great watch.

[bojinns]

+1 on Exp II...my daily everywhere timepiece..but then again..my only watch ;(

[polarinda]

Exp ii polar?

anyday.

[77T]

Which PO?

2908.50.91




-----or-----


2918.50.82




If yours is a 2908, then fairly good trade value considering he wants avg. retail on a good pre-owned Expl.II A serial or better. Keep the GP and make up the delta in cash, or trade it, I can't really say much about it. DavidSW has one for sale on TRF for $3900-ish perhaps compare yours to his?

But if yours is a 2918, then that's a low-ball trade offer - I'd just walk away from the deal.

[Gaijin]

The Explorer II is my daily wearer. I would do it.

[kilyung]

If you don't wear the Omega or GP... trade.