audemars vs rolex

[joelmm]

hey guys... im looking forward to buy buy my first watch...
i have the choice between a rolex daytona steel and an audemars royal oak 15400...
im in a little struggle, beacause i can't decide



thanks

[Jaycnyp]

White or black dial Daytona?

[joelmm]

Originally Posted by Jaycnyp

White or black dial Daytona?

black dial

[Jaycnyp]

In this case I would take the AP. it's a beautiful piece regardless of dial color. I'm not a fan of the black SS daytona

[joelmm]

Originally Posted by Jaycnyp

In this case I would take the AP. it's a beautiful piece regardless of dial color. I'm not a fan of the black SS daytona

which watch has more value after using it?

[Thatguy]

Originally Posted by joelmm

which watch has more value after using it?

Relative to retail price? Rolex


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[joelmm]

Originally Posted by Thatguy

Relative to retail price? Rolex


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

which watch would you take?

[Mr DateJust]

They are really different watches. The Daytona is a nice watch especially the black dial and is probably more useable and robust for everyday use. The AP is a step up from a Rolex. Much less common and more unique. The finishing on them is second to none. However while it could be an every day watch too I would argue it's not quite as robust plus service costs on AP are pretty steep.

[AK797]

AP for me.

[Time Exposure]

Daytona > AP 15400, but! AP ROC > Daytona.
I'm a big fan of complications (except when it comes time to servicing). And the black dial 116520 Daytona is my favorite of all Rolex models. Seriously! If I won a Platona or President or SkyD, I would sell it immediately to fund the 116520 and keep the change.
Okay, fantasy, I know. But you catch my drift? The stainless Daytona black dial rocks!

[evlkoala]

AP first

[Urosfan]

Between those two I'd pick ap

[thomaspp]

Calling @jjnd08 .... Rolf

Love both. AP more unique, Daytona a classic.

[watchwatcher]

Which one fits your lifestyle and your sense of style better? Go with that one.

[beshannon]

AP in this case, I found the black dial Daytona very difficult to read on my wrist

[s14roller]

Had both. Still have 15400.

[rodrob59]

If it were me, and it's not, I would get the Royal Oak, it is THE dressy sport watch IMHO. Then consider a gently used Speedmaster Pro when finances permit. I don't know, but suspect, that the Speedy isn't as popular in Europe as the US, but I like it more than the Daytona and the price compared to the Daytona, is reasonable. Again, just my opinion, but feel free to make it yours. I don't see you being disappointed with either choice.

[GB-man]

AP for me. It's painful to scratch the bezel, but if you take relatively good care of it there's no problems.

If the Daytona had a ceramic bezel and brushed center links it would have my heart and wallet. Until then...

[locutus49]

Daytona is more durable and reliable, and requires service every 10 years. If you are rich, go for the AP and be prepared for service costs.

[Manofsteelpt]

Originally Posted by locutus49

Daytona is more durable and reliable, and requires service every 10 years. If you are rich, go for the AP and be prepared for service costs.

Lol

AP all day... Surprised most selected AP in the Rolex section.

[superdog]

Originally Posted by locutus49

Daytona is more durable and reliable, and requires service every 10 years. If you are rich, go for the AP and be prepared for service costs.

buying a $10,000 + watch either way...

[GB-man]

Originally Posted by superdog

buying a $10,000 + watch either way...

have to agree

[Lemarp]

Originally Posted by superdog

buying a $10,000 + watch either way...

[NoVaSubowner]

Go AP! I did and it made me wonder why I waited......(Besides being able to reach a point where I could swing it)

[improviz]

Originally Posted by locutus49

Daytona is more durable and reliable, and requires service every m10 years. If you are rich, go for the AP and be prepared for service costs.

Establish empirically that APs are less reliable or durable than Rolex. Also please compare servicing costs for a 15400 to a Daytona and post this data here, since you have obviously (not) researched it.

Also, my Daytona servicing booklet states three to five year service intervals if memory serves, it is definitely not ten. If yours says ten, would you be so kind as to snap a pic and post it?

[NoVaSubowner]

I live here in the DC area and the Sub is almost common as the potholes in the winter.

I don't think it has anything to do with who "you rub shoulders with" I think it has to do more with the desire to own an iconic watch that is made by one of the big 3 manufacturers.

[chucelli]

Originally Posted by NoVaSubowner

I live here in the DC area and the Sub is almost common as the potholes in the winter.

I don't think it has anything to do with who "you rub shoulders with" I think it has to do more with the desire to own an iconic watch that is made by one of the big 3 manufacturers.

I think you misunderstood me.
You are saying the same thing as me. The "who you rub shoulders with" comment was referring to the fact that you will be disappointed if you are after exclusivity, as depending on the crowd, an AP can be as common as the Rolex in a different crowd. I know a few AP owners in the DC area, but non are WIS'ers or know about TRF, or care to post pics of their watch on the internet.
Not sure about the Sub being "almost common as the potholes in the winter" comment, as I also live in the DC area. Nevermind the DC area, the Sub is probably the most common watch here on TRF.
That said, does that make the Sub any less desirable?
Obviously not to me since I own one...

[NoVaSubowner]

Originally Posted by chucelli

I think you misunderstood me.
You are saying the same thing as me. The "who you rub shoulders with" comment was referring to the fact that you will be disappointed if you are after exclusivity, as depending on the crowd, an AP can be as common as the Rolex in a different crowd. I know a few AP owners in the DC area, but non are WIS'ers or know about TRF, or care to post pics of their watch on the internet.
Not sure about the Sub being "almost common as the potholes in the winter" comment, as I also live in the DC area. Nevermind the DC area, the Sub is probably the most common watch here on TRF.
That said, does that make the Sub any less desirable?
Obviously not to me since I own one...

So we had a circular conversation...like it never happens in DC.....???

[NoVaSubowner]

Actually I have only seen 2 Royal Oaks in DC since owning mine for almost a year..... A lot of offshores, but few Royal Oaks.

[jjnd08]

@thomaspp Called on the right guy!

I had a Daytona as an only watch for 18 months, and I traded it towards a 15400 black dial 2 months ago and haven't looked back.

I wasn't a RO fan, but the AD insisted I try one on. Once I did, I didn't want to take it off, and my Daytona lost a lot of luster. You just can't beat the fit, finishing, and the RO bracelet. This watch is perfect for the office with the seamless clasp (Daytona's protrudes and is bulky) and low profile, it just slides under the shirt cuff; while the 41mm lets it be a bit sporty too with short sleeves.

Oh, and the dial is gorgeous, especially under a loupe.

For those that say it isn't suitable as a daily are just flat wrong - unless they are professional divers. The WR resistance isn't as good as a Daytona, but the watch can handle showers or a dip in the pool. I'm reading the Royal Oak Anniversary Book now, thanks to Thomas, and having adequate water resistance was a requirement in the watch design.

As far as scratches go, due to the PCLs, scratches are WAY more prevalent on the Daytona than the RO. The slimmer profile also keeps it closer to the wrist and out of harms way. It does hurt more when a scratch does happen, but that's because the watch is so beautiful and pricey. But mine looks better than my Daytona did after the same amount of time.

As far as servicing costs, the Daytona is about $850, and the RO is about $1100. Not a huge difference over a 5-7 year time span.

My only regret about making the switch? I waited 3 months to do so from the first time I tried it on.

Pictures below tell the story. Last one isn't mine.

:mic drop:



Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk