Should I do this trade? 126613+126600 for a Pepsi

[SDR581]

Morning all!!

I've been wanting a Pepsi for a few years now with no calls from my AD.

A trusted forum dealer offered me an unworn 126710BLRO for my 126613LB and 126600.

Should I? I can only wear one watch at a time, though I love my blusey.

Sent from my SM-S908U using Tapatalk

[Hougenie]

Of course up to you OP but personally I wouldn't
2 lovely watches you're thinking of trading. I guess it depends what others you have that may do a similar job

Sent from my RMX2001 using Tapatalk

[rmlovett1]

Those particular two, for the SS Pepsi….me personally….no way. YMMV

[101031-28]

Originally Posted by richris1

those particular two, for the ss pepsi….me personally….no way. Ymmv

+1

[Porschen]

I have a 126710BLRO and adore the watch…but I wouldn’t trade the pieces you mention for it. Yours will come at your AD eventually. Best of luck :)

Mine took about 2.5 years at my AD.

[travisb]

You'd be giving up way too much.
Keep the LB and trade the 126600 + cash for the BLRO. Perfect pair.

[brandrea]

Not a fair trade at all IMO. I’d keep one of the divers and add cash for the BLRO. A diver/GMT is a great duo

[Bladeshot]

Nope. I’ve had the ceramic Pepsi. It’s not worth 2 for 1 trade. You’ve got 2 nice watches. Wait until you can add it. Or trade one plus cash.

Pepsi is high teens. Your watches are mid teens, each. You’re “paying way too much”.


Just another WIS who loves to trade.
IG @bladeandwatch1

[MrMercedes]

Sorry, but you would be completely insane to do that.

[MattyL147]

Not a bluesy fan but this is still a def no! You’re paying wayyyy too much in trade for that Pepsi.

[1William]

Not a fair trade. Way too much into the BLRO for the two you are trading. You should get 3-5K back.

[Kiddodoc]

I own all 3 pieces and there is no way in hell I would give up a bluesy and an SD43 for the Pepsi. While I enjoy my Pepsi, I actually prefer the BLNR. Will be curious to see what you decide.

[JRell]

Originally Posted by Kiddodoc

I own all 3 pieces and there is no way in hell I would give up a bluesy and an SD43 for the Pepsi. While I enjoy my Pepsi, I actually prefer the BLNR. Will be curious to see what you decide.

So you do like the BLNR more than the BLRO? I have been wanting to add a 124060 back, but felt it was to close to the BLNR so was thinking of exchanging at my AD for the BLRO. Also have the 12LV.

[Kiddodoc]

Originally Posted by JRell

So you do like the BLNR more than the BLRO? I have been wanting to add a 124060 back, but felt it was to close to the BLNR so was thinking of exchanging at my AD for the BLRO. Also have the 12LV.

I do prefer the BLNR to the BLRO but both can exist in a collection in my opinion. I had the BLNR but sold it with other watches to attain the platinum Daytona. I bought the BLRO from my AD so couldn’t sell it and bought the BLNR from a gray dealer. My AD will get the BLRN. Waiting for a white SS Daytona too.

Love my 126600 which zi think is the best all around diver from Rolex. The Pepsi bezel looks off in bright sun. The BLNR does not.

[JRell]

Originally Posted by Kiddodoc

I do prefer the BLNR to the BLRO but both can exist in a collection in my opinion. I had the BLNR but sold it with other watches to attain the platinum Daytona. I bought the BLRO from my AD so couldn’t sell it and bought the BLNR from a gray dealer. My AD will get the BLRN. Waiting for a white SS Daytona too.

Love my 126600 which zi think is the best all around diver from Rolex. The Pepsi bezel looks off in bright sun. The BLNR does not.

Thank you! This is huge info for me. I am big on consistent colors. If the BLRO looks off in the sunlight that is a major no for me. Love the BLNR in both sunlight and night. Appreciate the feedback. Good luck with the Daytona, I am waiting for either dial color SS Daytona.

[Watchesnguitars]

Not a good trade imo


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[watchwatcher]

Never, EVER trade a watch you love.

At the price point Pepsi's are going nowadays, just buy one. Or, worst case, scenario, trade the other watch for it.

[rohada]

I have a Pepsi and love it. But, I'd trade it to get those two watches in a heartbeat. However, if I owned those two watches, I would not make that trade. Though I'm assuming full sets, I still wouldn't do it for less than complete sets. Monetarily, you're giving up a lot for a Pepsi, at least at current transaction levels. You can see this quickly on eBay and C24, as a ballpark reference point. But, if the BLRO is your end all, be all, then by all means...

[KyloRen]

I recently made a trade

16700 + 126300 for new old stock BLRO.

I wouldnt make the trade if I am you. I would do 126600 + cash for pepsi. However dealer dont make much for SD now which is sad.

[fskywalker]

No way

[JRell]

The BLRO is a 10k SS watch, heck no!

[Easy E]

Not a good value trade.

[faust munihausen]

That trade is a rip off.
I wouldn't do it.

[JSolution]

Absolutely not can’t believe you had to ask. You’d be better off selling the two and buying the blro with cash left in your pocket.

[vitadine]

Originally Posted by JSolution

Absolutely not can’t believe you had to ask. You’d be better off selling the two and buying the blro with cash left in your pocket.

This

[RogerOP]

Heck no!

That’s a terrible trade.

[Duey]

I've got a NIB BLRO

I'll do the deal with you and give you $1k

[SDR581]

Thinking you guys are right. Love the blusey too much. Might do the 126600 and cash.

[garyk]

Nope, no way I would do that deal. Big regret later on….

[minute_man]

Horrible trade.