Gator leather. Is there a difference?

[SJK]

I know everything there is to know about cow leather, but I don't have a single clue when it comes to gator leather such as tanning process, quality, cut, etc. etc.

I want to put an alligator strap on my DJ and was wondering if there is any difference in quality when it comes to alligator leather?

For example, the alligator leather used on an oem strap from Rolex vs aftermarket alligator strap from a general watch store. Are these hides churned out by the masses and thrown out into the market or do they have higher end producers such as "Horween (cordovan)" who put more care and attention into their hides and are sourced by Rolex, PP, JLC, etc?

I want to know if there is a difference in what I'm paying for. If all alligator leather is the same, then it will make things so much more easier for me as I will just look for whatever looks good and the cheapest pricing available. If not, then I want to be able to differentiate quality vs cost.

Thanks!

[JohnBoy]

My experience is somewhat limited, but, to me, there is a big difference in the quality and pattern of alligator straps. The cheaper straps are, of course, just cowhide with the alligator pattern embossed. Nothing wrong with them - more functional and tough - just not very pretty (<$20). Then there are the more-repetetive, small-veined patterns - probably real alligator, no doubt from the younger ones, usually very glossy, relatively thin, cheaply made - stitched or glued to their leather backs (say $15-$40). The more expensive (executive) straps tend to be less-glossy-to-matte finished, finely stitched, and might have unique, non-repetetive, patterns - probably from the older alligators (say >$40-$200+). There also seems to be a difference in where the aligator in question is from - Louisiana gator (vs. import) is typically more expensive. Ditto most of the above for crocodile and lizard straps. A good way to compare is to visit some of the custon strap-maker websites and see what pattern and skin do to the cost and buyer appeal.

Aside from the embossed cowhide straps, I don't think any of the reptile skin straps tend to be very scuff- or sweat-resistant, but, they are made for a different purpose - dress. I wouldn't wear them on my tool watches very near my tool box. Does this help?

[Dr. Robert]

I have my datejust on a Rolex made black Java lizard strap......I have had good luck w/ them, they last & are well made.

[GermanyMatt]

Prior to selling my 70's 18k DD, I installed a new Hadley Roma gator strap. I was very pleased with the quality. The Rolex lizard band it replaced barely lasted a year.

[blue lion]

You get what you pay for but I love gator on boots and watch bands.

[patek.wis]

Peter on TZ has some great quality stuff. Mid 100s to almost 200 per strap, so you get what you pay for. Quality like I said is great and he can custom some things
Just ordered 2 straps for my dualmatic and was worth the price - quick ship too