is Tudor worth it?

[Elusion]

This thread got a little out of hand. Probably due to my poor wording in the first post.

I have no problem with ETA. It's just "everywhere" for various sums of money.

I just wanted to know if I'd be getting the most out of my money with a THC. It sounds like I would. From what you've all said, it seems that the braclet, case, etc are made buy Tudor for only Tudor, which I like.

My Watch Wish List is short but I think I'm adding the THC to it. Now I need an AD near me.

[tinger]

Here's a review on the 2892. Not a chrono movement, but a good read.
http://www.chronometrie.com/eta2892/eta2892.html

Last paragraph:
'So how does it compare to the competition? There are some movements that match it in terms of accuracy and reliability, but in my humble opinion, none exceed it. The Rolex 3035 and 3135 match it toe to toe. But they are a lot thicker and considerably more expensive too. The PPs, while being very pretty to look at, do not match it for accuracy and are more delicate as far as reliability is concerned. Of course they’re also slightly thinner, so that does put them at a disadvantage. The JLC 889/2 does match it for accuracy, but is also too delicate to give it any competition in the reliability department. The main reason for the latter is its very weak mainspring. The whole design, while being well thought out and superbly executed, relies too much on everything being just perfect. It is just thrown out of wack too easily, when even minor things go out of adjustment. I don’t have too much experience on the Blancpain/Piguet movements. But from the few that have crossed my bench, they don’t seem to deliver the same accuracy that the 2892 has no trouble delivering. Let me know if I’ve left any of your favorite movements out, and I’ll gladly comment on them'

[ThePayola]

I love the look, the feel, the features, the accuracy...everything. When I'm wearing it, I have never once looked at it and though, "Gee...I'd like this watch so much more if it only had a different movement." It simply has no impact on my enjoyment of the watch, or the way I feel about its quality or value. I also enjoy the understated nature of the Tudor brand, especially since it's relatively unknown to most in the US where I live.

The OP said, "It costs about HALF what a Rolex costs but I keep thinking that I could use that money toward a Rolex." My mindset is exactly the opposite. I already own a Rolex (Explorer), but given my level of satisfaction with my Tudor, I would have a hard time justifying buying another new Rolex when I could buy two (or three) Tudors for the same money - especially if they keep churning out offerings like the Black Bay, Pelagos, etc. I won't abandon Rolexes altogether, but as I continue to build my collection, I expect to add plenty of Tudors.

[ThePayola]

Originally Posted by JAGERVEGAS

Black Bay is on my short list, wishing it had a date feature though., it would be the perfect underwater beach vacation watch with the vintage strap...price point is perfect, for me .

I agree the date feature would be nice, but if (actually, more like when) I pull the trigger on a Black Bay, I'll probably just use the rotating bezel to mark the date. Seems like a smart use of a feature that would probably otherwise go unused most of the time.

[Watchdog]

Tudor, to me, has some incredibly interesting offerings. The new blue is amazing.

Cheers!

[ThePayola]

Originally Posted by Elusion

This thread got a little out of hand. Probably due to my poor wording in the first post.

I have no problem with ETA. It's just "everywhere" for various sums of money.

I just wanted to know if I'd be getting the most out of my money with a THC. It sounds like I would. From what you've all said, it seems that the braclet, case, etc are made buy Tudor for only Tudor, which I like.

My Watch Wish List is short but I think I'm adding the THC to it. Now I need an AD near me.

Since Tudors still aren't available new through ADs in the US yet, I'd suggest looking for a trusted seller here on TRF or elsewhere who can find you one. I bought my THC pre-owned and saved about $1,300 vs. the cost of a new one, plus I avoided any customs charges. I couldn't tell mine from brand new. There are plenty out there to be had if you do a little digging.

[Chewbacca]

nobody will convince you of anything but if i could ad this for thought, ask whether a rolex is worth over double and triple (or more and more) of some tudors and then you'll be open to trying a tudor asap. if you want to be a rolex owner, that's different. if you want to build a solid collection, a tudor should be in the mix imo. good luck.

[Stellite]

If you like Rolex then Tudor is eventually a must have as they are siblings in my opinion. You will love the Tudor and I am certainly happy they are coming back to the US.

[landroverking]

Not the ETA part that keeps me away. Not the Tudor name either.
It's the Dubois piggyback chrono.

[Stellite]

Originally Posted by landroverking

Not the ETA part that keeps me away. Not the Tudor name either.
It's the Dubois piggyback chrono.

Well, I am not a chrono fan anymore, but the piggyback is not a problem. Some argue that it can be better to work on. Besides, Omega, Audemars Piquet, Glashutte Original and Tag have all used it with success(and I know there are more). Pretty good company imo. It's also thinner than the 7750 by a large margin and slightly thinner than the El Primero if I remember correctly.

[landroverking]

Well my TriBeCa is always miss firing. Second doesn't reset.
30 minute always off. Doesn't reset but to one.
This is now the 3rd time around. Never had this happen to a SMP or Heuer with the Valjous 72. Same as the vintage Daytona.

[crowncollection]

Nothing wrong with an eta. A workhorse and easy to get parts I love them.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[soho]

Originally Posted by Elusion

My Watch Wish List is short but I think I'm adding the THC to it. Now I need an AD near me.

I hope that you get one! Tudors are fantastic watches, and I think you will really enjoy it if you get one. Consider going vintage and/or through a TRF seller, so you don't need to wait on your AD.

[Ristretto]

The black bay is a nice watch in three forms, leather, nylon or bracelet it looks amazing.

[SUBversive]

It's not a matter of convincing you op. it's up to you to decide if its worth it. I think the price point for Tudor is high, yes close to rolex new and equal to pre owned rolex for sure.

[John in MA]

I think they are worth it though I'm always about buying a 6mo old one for considerably less.

If you want a THC absolutely do it. I own one and was so impressed I just bought a Pelagos even though I own two vintage snowflakes.

It is possible to find them for a good discount. I got my THC for $2800 and it was just bought new in Oct. 2012.

[padi56]

Originally Posted by Elusion

This thread got a little out of hand. Probably due to my poor wording in the first post.

I have no problem with ETA. It's just "everywhere" for various sums of money.

I just wanted to know if I'd be getting the most out of my money with a THC. It sounds like I would. From what you've all said, it seems that the braclet, case, etc are made buy Tudor for only Tudor, which I like.

My Watch Wish List is short but I think I'm adding the THC to it. Now I need an AD near me.

Well same could be said about Rolex they are every-where and for various sums of money.

[Stellite]

Originally Posted by landroverking

Well my TriBeCa is always miss firing. Second doesn't reset.
30 minute always off. Doesn't reset but to one.
This is now the 3rd time around. Never had this happen to a SMP or Heuer with the Valjous 72. Same as the vintage Daytona.

I do think anyone can get a chrono lemon. I have owned many el primeros by different companies, most being very accurate and reliable, though not so stout. However, I had one that it seemed to be more like a true lemon, nickle and diming me to death. I finally had it and got rid of it cheap. But I have not had a piggy back so can't say in that case.

[kuya808]

Is Tudor worth it....Absolutely!!!