Please help me decide today subC and - hulk vs BLNr

[smc23]

Hello TRF

Great community we have here. So I've been reading the site for a few years now and have just registered. I'm really torn on a second watch that would complement well with my SubC black 116610LN for a weekend watch.

I've literally gone through the entire Rolex line to find a notable companion to the SubC. To the point of even deciding on the WG sub! But in the end the durability of SS and obvious cost factor won out. So I narrowed it down to the infamous two - 116610LV Hulk OR 116710BLNR

Availability of the HuLk is 6-8wk wait around here, but am willing to wait if this is the best option.

Almost going insane trying it decide only one if of these as they are both beautiful watches. Lol

SMc

[swils8610]

I've owned all three....I still have the BLNR. I love the polished center links and the sporty yet dressy style of it. Can't go wrong with any of your choices thiugh!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Muzz]

As you already have a sub I would recommend the BLNR. Then,you,would,have the best of both worlds,so to speak.

[datejust24]

personally i'd go with the BLNR I just can't get past those pcl's...OR unless your absolutely sold on ceramic go with the 16610LV...that'd be my choice..but its your wrist.

[leicashot]

I recently bought the Hulk as my only Rolex and as beautiful as it is the green was a little too much beauty to be wearing every day so I went for my initial choice the Sea Dweller and couldn't be happier. So I suggest the BLNR or Sub LN.

For my the green dial wasn't the issue as much as the green bezel

[smc23]

Originally Posted by Muzz

As you already have a sub I would recommend the BLNR. Then,you,would,have the best of both worlds,so to speak.

This was my same thinking, but then we rarely travel to different timezone so that use of the watch would be more of a nice to have feature.

Btw - I've read through the many hulk vs batman threads but hopefully this one puts into perspective that the new watch would need to complement the Black dial SuBC. Hopefully this helps someone else...

[antbkny]

if you have a subc now, i would pick up the gmt to go along with it

[Speed]

I think the green hulk is a bit if a novelty with limited wearing potential. It's all green afterall.

The other choices are much more versatile - unless you are willing to wear a very green watch as often as another.

[Time Exposure]

I'd be inclined to suggest the BLNR for its GMT complication. But based on the "good in pictures, disappointed in person" thread here, make sure you spend time with it in different light (showroom, natural) before you part with the cash.

[brandrea]

I'd go the blnr for reasons mentioned above. Neil in Florida has one for sale right now

[Qristian]

I would sell the SubC and buy both Hulk and BLNR. Otherwise you have either two black dialled watches or two same model watches.

[The Libertine]

Originally Posted by Muzz

As you already have a sub I would recommend the BLNR. Then,you,would,have the best of both worlds,so to speak.

+1. More than one modern Submariner is, well, redundant. Get the BLNR. Different watch, different function, different bracelet - it's an entirely different watch and will nicely compliment your existing Submariner.

[AK797]

BLNR to partner the Subc. Also look at the blue YM, also has blue and more differentiated.

[AndyK]

Originally Posted by Muzz

As you already have a sub I would recommend the BLNR. Then,you,would,have the best of both worlds,so to speak.

Agree

[smc23]

Originally Posted by Qristian

I would sell the SubC and buy both Hulk and BLNR. Otherwise you have either two black dialled watches or two same model watches.

This partly crossed my mind, as I would love to have both, even at one point regretting my decision on the SubC, as I had the option at the time to buy either Hulk or BLNR.

The SubC has sentimental value though being it was my graduation present and a reflection for my first child so this is not an option unfortunately.

[smc23]

Originally Posted by AK797

BLNR to partner the Subc. Also look at the blue YM, also has blue and more differentiated.

Took a look at the YM series, and the new blue dial was in the running for a bit, but fell short as I already have an older blue dial DJ, and more so the inevitable scratches that would get put on the platinum bezel.

[Cru Jones]

to go with your 116610LN, either the LVc, 216570 or daytona. personally, i wouldn't pair a blue/black GMT with a black submariner date. good luck with your choice.

[Mystro]

Go with the GMT. Its a different animal than your Sub but will wear the same.

[beshannon]

The GMT without a doubt

[thomaspp]

BLNR for me

[Urosfan]

Since u have a sub go for blnr

[ZROLEX]

I would do BLNR if I had to chose

[lipjin]

I need to sell a couple watches so I can buy the Hulk again :( Hulk is my choice!

[AMCK87]

In your situation, I'd actually aim for a white-faced Daytona. Gives you two completely different watches (casual vs. dressy, brushed vs. polished, dive vs. chrono, etc.) and arguably the two greatest sports models Rolex produces. If you must stick to the two options you mentioned, BLNR is the way to go, IMO.

[Landshark33]

I have paired my SubC with the 42mm polar Exp2. Great contrast to to the sub- white dial, a bit larger, no ceramic bezel, larger hands, and 2nd timezone function. I think a few others on TRF have chosen this combo as well..

[Deyn Man]

Originally Posted by AMehta87

In your situation, I'd actually aim for a white-faced Daytona. Gives you two completely different watches (casual vs. dressy, brushed vs. polished, dive vs. chrono, etc.) and arguably the two greatest sports models Rolex produces. If you must stick to the two options you mentioned, BLNR is the way to go, IMO.

+2
Made perfect sense when I read it...

But between the two, it would be a tough choice if I were in your shoes... Batman would be the obvious choice since it is a different model. But you mentioned that the GMT feature will not be used much? To non-WIS, the batman may look the same as your SubC Date.. So voting for the Hulk... Although it is the same watch as your SubC Date, the all green dial and bezel makes it very different...

Good luck on choosing man! :-) such a nice problem to have :-)

[Casey VP-26]

116610lv

[T01]

Blnr!

[Art 1]

I would much rather have the BLNR and in fact made that choice. The AD had 3 LVc's in stock in the case, too common for me to want. I had to order the BLNR and they rarely get those in.

[btinl]

I own both the SubC LN and LV. I would choose the LV over the BLNR based upon the PCL bracelet alone. I'm not a huge fan of PCLs on a tool watch.