How much is warranty worth to you?

[e2phantom]

Hi folks,

Fed up with AD games and looking to buy gray. Without getting into exact prices as I know that specifically is against the rules, I'm curious to hear what members think warranty is worth. I am looking at a few 116500s - most all are in excellent or near mint condition. Let's call their conditions equal for this purpose. Given Rolex's 5-year warranty, each of these has some left...

Option 1 - Warranty Dated September 2017
Option 2 - Warranty Dated September 2019

Again, without getting into prices of the watches themselves...Option 2 is $1k USD more than Option 1. Do you think the extra 2 years of warranty is worth $1k on a 116500? If this were a Tudor GMT, I'd say yes (sorry Tudor GMT, owners). But with the reliability of the 116500, I'm thinking the 2017 is a better buy.

FWIW, both watches are from the same trusted seller.