Case of the Blues

[RB971]

I’ve recently found myself not giving any wrist time to my DD36 18238. This is likely because I now very much prefer 40mm size. Since I’m not wearing the DD36 much, I’ve decided to trade it in (no papers) for a YM 126622. My dilema is I like the blue dial (from pictures) but already own two blue dials.

Two questions:
-Would this be a fair trade?
-In person, do you prefer the blue or rhodium YM?

Current collection:
116613LB
DJ41 Blue
BB58 Black dial
PAM388

Thanks all!!