Thinking of another Rolex but conflicted

[Formulansx]

I'm kicking around the idea of picking up a second Rolex and I thought I had it nailed down to a 116333 DJII with the slate dial/green outline roman numerals. I was looking around and I stumbled on a 18038 day date president white dial/stick markers that looks realllllllly good. Now I'm running off in the head about gold Rolex's and such. I tried on the DJII at my local AD the other day and it's very nice. I have a 36mm datejust now and I do like the larger 41mm size of the DJII but I just can't get the day date out of my head. Is this a good idea to pick up a 27 or so year old day date vs a new DJII?? I can't reach for a larger Day date II unfortunately without selling something I don't want to sell.