Explorer II (40mm) for Explorer II (42mm)-- Would you do it?

[toomuchtalk]

Interesting.
I have the old red hand explorers-
And the new versions.
I think they are totally different watches.
The red hand polar version is the definitive explorer 2- not counting the original orange hand- that's the benchmark.
The better watch for expeditions is the new orange hand white dial. And that's the point: for expeditions. The dial is amazing for viewing in low light- better movement- better clasp.
The black dial is better for all round daily use- it's a dressier watch.
The red hand versions are gorgeous and will do the job they are designed for. But you can't read the time at 4am in the morning inside a tent. You can with the new version.

So, if you want the best watch for use on an expedition- and that's what the explorer is meant to do!
Get the new explorer 2. White .

If you don't do expeditions- but love a GMT function and a robust watch get the black.

If you love the vintage feel keep the one you have: because it is better proportioned and looks better on the wrist.
Just my take on it.