Best Datejust 41 or II out of these

[heath.1967]

hello guys i'm torn between these watches could somebody help me ?
i'm trying to find the flashiest amongst them.

Dark Rhodium Diamond Marker Fluted bezel Datejust II year 2014.
Wimbledon Dial Two Tone Datejust II fluted bezel year 2015.
Brand New Dark Rhodium Diamond Marker Fluted bezel DJ41 in oyster/jubilee with new 3225.

does polishing the Datejust (The Preowned) could affect the shine of the watch ? especially the fluted bezel.because i actually doesn't mind about the new movement/the jubilee strap,as long as it could shine the same as the BNIB DJ41,i would prefer to spend 2000USD less by buying the preowned one.

thanks for your helps guys.