Is 2 explorers 2 too much of exploration ?

[mimisiq]

I have a black explorer 2 with new novement. I like it a lot. I bought it before the price increase for 3 600 euros on the grey market. Now the same watch is sold 4 250 euros by the same seller. So good deal.

The same seller is selling now a second hand white explorer 2 from 2008 (with the old movement so) in "new" shape. The watch was sold buy an AD in 2010 and is therefore under Rolex warranty till 2012. The price is 3 400 euros.

My questions are :

1) Is 2 explorers 2 too much ?

2) Is the price a good price ?

3) Would you buy an explorer 2 with the old movement or prefer the new one because it may hold its value better in a few years .

Thanks