Is vintage ever a good deal?

[Rob519]

So I've been looking for a good deal on a vintage Rolex sports watch, and the Explorer II 16570 Polar with tritium is a top contender (under $4500 and because I think it's cool).

Here's the problem...

I could buy a newer 16570 with less worries about accuracy or condition for about the same price. Also, the added benefits of lume and better clasp bracelet with SEL. However, arguably not as unique (without patina or age).

So how is vintage ever a good deal? If you want the watch to be all original, you're going to avoid servicing. Yes it's cool, but for the same amount of money you get better reliability/accuracy. Especially, if you plan on keeping it for life.

Would love to hear the community's thoughts on this. Not trying to be combative, as I totally get the coolness factor of something really old/historical. Just having a hard time justifying the long term value.