Help with Dials

[katester]

I'm in a market for a pre-owned Rolex but I haven't worn one or inspected one up close so I decided to go to my local AD. I'm pretty much set at MOP Diamond Dial Lady DJ prior but the manager and rep there strongly recommended that I'd be better off with just the champagne or the silver. They have shown me a used one that they have for sale which somehow the dial surface is not flat and she insisted that because it is natural, it deteriorates and become irregular over time.....true?

Other dials that I was considering are the rhodium and silver jubilee which they are also very opposed to.

I was told rhodium is too dark and is not very popular thus not a good investment. All they have is the dark rhodium (the midsize DJ floral) so I have not yet to see a real rhodium that is almost close to silver.

They also do not have a sample of a silver jubilee dial to show. The rep is wearing an older style jubilee dial which looks matted and not shiny at all as oppose to what I see online that is almost 3d. She said jubilee dials are outdated so I should stick with a plain dial that will stay classic for a lifetime.

What are your thoughts on this....I really appreciate it!