Patek 5170P long term collectability ?

[benlee]

I am quite close to pulling the trigger on a 5170P, baring any new pieces that I will like even more this coming Baselworld. I have been eyeing this for a long time. In person, it's a stunning watch and without question the nicest of the 5170 series and one of the most beautiful PP I have seen. The fact that it has this amazing blue dial and in platinum ( I don't have platinum watches ) makes all the more desirable.

However, 5170s isn't known to have great resale. Even 5170P which is a short run, it is not difficult to find them in AD, at least for now. My Patek sales rep however is convinced that they will soon fly off the shelves given that it's discontinued. However, historical evidence seems to suggest 5170s are slow movers even if they are discontinued. I can still find 5170J or G lingering at AD display unsold.

I haven't collect PP long enough to know what happen to 5070s but I was told these didn't take off until the entire line was discontinued and prices went thru the roof.

Usually I don't care too much about resale for most watches, but at this price point, I will be dishonest to say it doesn't matter.

Another curveball suggestion will be to top up more and get the 5740G instead which, according to many have nearly "guaranteed" collectivity as a Nautilus.

Insights from fellow collectors here are much appreciated. Thanks in advance.

BTW, throw in a pic of 5170P for good measure.






The 5740G Perpetual calendar Nautilus in white gold.