Insurance options other than JM?

[nmaddix]

I was mugged back in September, my GMT Master II was stolen (and my nose busted up pretty bad, hooray). It was insured through Jewelers Mutual and I just bought a DD40 as a replacement using the policy.

JM won't insure the new DD40 due to my past claim, so who is a good option as an alternative to insure the watch?

I don't have a homeowner's policy and am not military for USAA.

I've reviewed other threads on insurance companies but figured I'd start a fresh thread on this since the posts are a bit old.

I may try Gemsafe, but I figure there must be other options.