Rolex DD vs Patek Philippe

[Trurolexer]

I'm a FANATIC kinda Guy. Just interesting with Rolex and no other brand.
But this time, to be honest I must netral to decide between 'em...Well...still DD the WINNAH. lol!!! CHOOSE DD!!!

[Otto]

[QUOTE=redshirt1957;576843]Almost pulled the trigger on a couple of DDs, but the wife just does not like them. For a dress watch she perfers something along the lines of a Patek Philippe. The PP that we both like is 34mm? Tried it on and it looked fine and any PP will feel slight after wearing a 40mm Rolex. Just asking your opinions on Rolex DD vs Patek Philippe and the watch pictured below. Be honest and blunt if needed.

Show her this one. It's my DD with the original dial configuration (I now have a champagne dial with luminova stick markers). My wife liked the "vintage" look (a stretch maybe, but I saw her point!) of the white dial w/romans on the DD.

The Patek is a great watch. The DD will give you more flexibility in use. IMO, the Patek is a good dress watch to have in the safe, ready to go for the right occasion.

[nhdblfan]

You seemed to be leaning towards the DD and are only considering the PP as your wife likes it better."You" are the one who the watch is for and will be looking at it more than she does.I have very little say in what my wife wears and drives nor does she in my choices and I like it that way.
If you go the DD be sure to go for the post Y series with the heavier braclet/new clasp.The 118238's have a much nicer feel.At least try one on before you jump on that Patek.Nice watch but a whole different look then the Rolex, I looked a them and try warm up to one but I think my next all gold is going to be a Rolex as well.

Another one you could show her,gold sticks light/champ;

[redshirt1957]

[QUOTE=Otto;576927]

Originally Posted by redshirt1957

The Patek is a great watch. The DD will give you more flexibility in use. IMO, the Patek is a good dress watch to have in the safe, ready to go for the right occasion.

Originally Posted by nhdblfan

You seemed to be leaning towards the DD and are only considering the PP as your wife likes it better.

That should do the trick. Great looking DDs.

Also...thanks to all that posted. Very good opinions and advice.

[entropydave]

I wish I had your problem!

[llamaofdoom]

I'd go with a 37-38mm Patek, personally...34mm is just too small for me.

[Mort]

Originally Posted by llamaofdoom

I'd go with a 37-38mm Patek, personally...34mm is just too small for me.

The 37mm is the perfect size. I had to look hard to find a used Calatrava that was not 34mm. Still had I found one I liked, I most likley would of bought it.

[rpryan55]

Both. But if you have to choose, the PP. It will soon be worth more than you paid for it, which is more than you can say for a new Rolex DD.

[Perdu]

Personally, I don't like that particular PP. Get what you want, not what your wife wants for you.

[applebook]

This decision depends a lot on what you plan on wearing the watch for. If you have a casual, office job, then then the PP is a great choice. However, if you're more active and plan on wearing the watch for golfing, then the Rolex is a wiser choice.

[nhdblfan]

Redshirt,
thank you for the compliment on my DD,Otto's, like all of his collection,which is outstanding, is very nice as well (I really like his white dial and Steves diamond dial DD-would be crazyy to own three) I hope thr expamples,along with maybe some others,are able to put the DD 118238's back in the front row .You really have to go try one on before you pull the trigger on anything.
You asked for opinions with no holding back and responded to the opinions like a champ
Whatever you chose, emphasis on "you chose",you will wear it well and be happy.Great thread and looking forward to seeing your new watch whatever it turns out to be
Best,
Dave

[Triple Black 88]

Redshirt, the Patek looks a little frail and I've never been fond of the leather strap. I'm suprised you are comparing these 2 watches because they wear totally different. The Patek is very thin and more subtle. The DD is much more hefty so it depends on your style. The DD comes in many different styles...WG/YG/Plat and tons of different dials, bezels, etc...
It sounds like you've made a decision...can't wait to see the pics.
Here is mine. YG w/Light Champaign Diamond Dial.

[redshirt1957]

Thanks for your personal opinions. That is exactly what I wanted. Many times I have given the advice "just buy what you like" to others. Sound advice. In this case I am not sure just what I like and I do not want to make an expensive mistake. One could ask why would I even give a rats turd what others think; he just need to make up his own mind. Well, in this case I am using sage advice that is; when in doubt ask and listen. I have heard and I know my decision. You guys pointed out specifics of each watch that I just have not noticed. Thanks. Off to make a purchase tomorrow.

[Lol-x]

You know this is a Rolex forum so my advice is going to have that kind of slant.

The Bark DD with timber dial is not to my personal tastes at all, and so I think that was a very poor example of the DD to show your wife in seeking her advice.

There are some versions of the DD that look spectacular.

A DD isn't just a dress watch either, it has a utilitarian flare to be worn on any occasion and it has the oyster case to give you a level of water resistance comfort.

The Patek is a great watch, the leather straps are different than the Rolex metal bracelets. Up to you which you prefer, but the Rolex metal bracelet looks great and wears really well.

Go to the shop with the Patek in one hand and the DD in the other and ask yourself which one feels more worthy, I bet you will pick the DD.

[redshirt1957]

Originally Posted by Lol-x

You know this is a Rolex forum so my advice is going to have that kind of slant.

The Bark DD with timber dial is not to my personal tastes at all, and so I think that was a very poor example of the DD to show your wife in seeking her advice.

There are some versions of the DD that look spectacular.

A DD isn't just a dress watch either, it has a utilitarian flare to be worn on any occasion and it has the oyster case to give you a level of water resistance comfort.

The Patek is a great watch, the leather straps are different than the Rolex metal bracelets. Up to you which you prefer, but the Rolex metal bracelet looks great and wears really well.

Go to the shop with the Patek in one hand and the DD in the other and ask yourself which one feels more worthy, I bet you will pick the DD.

Perfect response. Thanks to all.

[kcmo]

Originally Posted by redshirt1957

Perfect response. Thanks to all.

I'm looking forward to hearing about your chosen piece!

[Letsgodiving]

That particular Patek looks a little feminine to me.

[teton]

fragility is a problem with all complications. Try changing the time of your Rolex near midnight a few times. How about rapidly starting and stop the chronograph on your Daytona and see what happens? Will the chronograph hands line up anymore? Even the rotating bezels on the subs. If you rotate them one too many times the rachet will no longer click.

The most reliable watch would be somethiing that has just 3 hands, and no moving bezels.

-Teton

[JohnEaton]

I want this one... maybe after the GV and the DSSD



I know it's plain, but I really like this one, in Rose, it's a 5196R.

[GMTJOHNNY]

I have the DD YG 18238 and it is a my Grail watch for sure. I am in the market for the PP 5127R since that does look elegant and certainly worthy of passing down.
But the SIZE of the Rolex makes me want to hold it in my hand and use it as a "tool" to smash the out of the pathetic petite Patek! I just need something SOLID on my wrist!

[jac67]

Tough choice.

Both are outstanding time-pieces, stylish, accurate and meticulously manufactured.

Go and try them both, and your question WILL be answered.


John.

[GMT8]

Best of luck, Bubba. I was recently in a similar situation with my wife. We went into the AD with an expectation (at least on my part) of picking out a DD, when the next thing I know I'm being dragged by my wife and the salesman to the Patek display. While I didn't like all of their watches, some were certainly tempting. Unfortunately (for my wife, that is), the only one I would have considered seriously (i.e., had the remotest chance of being able to afford) was a manual wind--and I greatly prefer the automatics. So a DD it will be, finances permitting. Ultimately, as others have said, it's to be your watch, but you can't completely ignore the WF (wife factor). Can't wait to see what you end up with. Mike

[Jedi]

Bubba, the PP model you show in your original post has a knurled bezel. I think that reference is discontinued. The current reference with a similar function can be found at this link. It's known as a 5134.

It won't fall apart when you clap your hands like some like to say, but it certainly isn't as tough as a Rolex, but then again, it wasn't built to be. The 5134 is indeed a dual timezone watch, but it's a manual wind. No biggie to me, as it just gives one an excuse to interact with the timepiece more often. It will keep excellent time. About +/-2 a day, without a COSC certificate.

It's not a DD, but it will keep it's value better.

[TempoKing]

Actually I will be selling mine, A super collectible 3588 automatic Calatrava for about 9k
Retail 38k

[redshirt1957]

Everybody, very honest and to the point comments. Just what I needed. Went to Capetown today and tried both on and ended up buying two. Neither one was a DD or PP. Will post pictures soon. One was a S model (1994 without a date) and the other was a Z and has deen discontinued. Without the sound advice I would have made a mistake and....THANKS TRF! This shall teach the wife to go out of town and leave me with three kids.

[Markg]

Originally Posted by redshirt1957

. Neither one was a DD or PP. Will post pictures soon.

what did you get???

[nhdblfan]

Your wifes out of town and you went and bought two Rolex's?
Man I hoped you used her credit card if so your my new hero !

[redshirt1957]

Originally Posted by nhdblfan

Your wifes out of town and you went and bought two Rolex's?
Man I hoped you used her credit card if so your my new hero !

Lets see how much see really loves me.

[East Bay Rider]

Looking forward to learning the rest of this story.
Pics please.

[nhdblfan]

Anybody heard from redshirt since his wife returned ? If he doesn't post in 24hrs maybe we should call the cops

doesn't look good,wifes leaves town,he sneaks out and buys two rolex's and when she comes home.................................