Submariner 124060 vs. Sea-Dweller 16600

[erico]

I'm planning my first Rolex purchase end of the year for my 40th birthday. Was originally thinking brand new 124060 all the way but now am kicking around the idea of a 16600. Very different I know but here are some things I'm thinking about:

124060

-Pros: Maxi dial; brighter lume (?); higher quality bracelet and I like the appearance of the clasp more; available brand new; available through local brick and mortar (grey); significantly better power reserve
-Cons: Clasp size (need to try on again); more expensive; more blingy
-Mixed: Ceramic (more robust but more flashy)

16600

-Pros: More unique; more of a tool / less blingy; more water resistance; cheaper
-Cons: Bracelet is lower quality and clinckier (?); don't like the appearance of the clasp as much; thicker (maybe slightly); only available used (in my price range); probably only available online; no AR coating (?); faded lume (?); clasp might not function as well (?); shorter power reserve
-Mixed: Date function without cyclops (slight pro as I don't really like the cyclops and I use the date function on my Seamaster); aluminum bezel (I'm not too worried about scratches)

Am I off base? Am I missing anything?

Let me know what you think about choosing between these two.

I may also consider a Sub 14060 depending on what's out there.

Thanks!