Help with collection - John Mayer vs. Nautilus vs. Aquanat

[KY..]

Originally Posted by Hemdog

I’m seeing you have a two tone bluesy and a full gold version- why?

Yep, exactly.
You beat me to it.
2-tone and full yellow bluesy feels like overkill for the size of the collection…

[anujkapur108]

Originally Posted by KY..

Yep, exactly.
You beat me to it.
2-tone and full yellow bluesy feels like overkill for the size of the collection…

Bluesy and full gold blue dial sub are def overkill. I initially wanted to move the TT on, but it has sentimental value to me. I bought the full gold bc it was offered to me by my AD and I thought why not. Instant regret because its so similar, but hey, you live once and blue is my favorite color.

I like the idea of selling the 1226618lb. I'll probably move that to get my next watch. I really like the green dial on the daytona, it looks awesome with a black shirt/sweater.

I do think the JM is expensive. I could get the Paul Newman for 40-45k and that's very nice too. Just something special about the green dial to me and the fact that its discontinued makes it feel more special.

[bkay001]

Wow, you’ve got an awesome collection already!

[usmc_k9_vet]

Originally Posted by anujkapur108

I have been wanting to venture out into Patek for a little while and for sure that is where I'm going next.

I mean.. doesn’t sound like you need the forum to tell you what to do.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[DK7]

i would go 5167a or better 5712a

[ts3]

John Mayer does not work for me. Not into green dials.

Aquanaut I passed on when 5167A was readily available for 15k. Not worth it for me back then and looks larger than I like on my 6.6 inch wrist.

Nautilus on a strap is a hard no.


I'd go 5711/1A or 5712/1A. Still enjoying the 5711 blue I got many years ago.

[bp1000]

Nautilus belongs on bracelet for me.
Aquanaut is really pricey on the second hand market, nice and for me is best in rose gold, ideally 5164r

As for the YG Daytona, I dont think I could bring myself to pay the second hand prices. It's nice but not that nice. It's probably my favourite of all three however. But the blue dial is equally impressive. Far more versatile, far cheaper.

[anujkapur108]

Alright guys. Y’all all helped and I’m reporting back. I traded the 126618lb plus cash for the Patek. But went with the 5711r. Thanks for everyone’s input. Nautilus def belongs on a bracelet.

[jb335]

Originally Posted by anujkapur108

Alright guys. Y’all all helped and I’m reporting back. I traded the 126618lb plus cash for the Patek. But went with the 5711r. Thanks for everyone’s input. Nautilus def belongs on a bracelet.

I approve! Well done


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[AG23]

Originally Posted by anujkapur108

Alright guys. Y’all all helped and I’m reporting back. I traded the 126618lb plus cash for the Patek. But went with the 5711r. Thanks for everyone’s input. Nautilus def belongs on a bracelet.

Awesome choice- congratulations

[Giangos]

Originally Posted by anujkapur108

Alright guys. Y’all all helped and I’m reporting back. I traded the 126618lb plus cash for the Patek. But went with the 5711r. Thanks for everyone’s input. Nautilus def belongs on a bracelet.

Outstanding choice


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[lord91]

Congrats, excellent choice!

[rmlovett1]

Well done! Congratulations!

[travisb]

Congratulations! That's a great choice!

[1William]

Congratulations.

[APhound]

Very nice! Love it


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[StackLexus17]

Bravo!

[Sergio_UKR]

Great choice. Looks beautiful!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk