Would you trade three steel watches for an oysterflex skydweller?

[Bxtek]

Definitely a no vote for me. That Sky-D is nice and a heavy hitter piece, but doesn't really do it for me, especially at the price of admission. I personally would get more enjoyment out of owning the 3 pieces that you already have.

I don't know how hot the market is on that Sky-D reference as I don't follow it. If it's soft, would it be better to sell all 3 pieces at a premium, then negotiate a good deal on a Sky-D purchase directly?

[Jonnewbank]

Originally Posted by Bxtek

Definitely a no vote for me. That Sky-D is nice and a heavy hitter piece, but doesn't really do it for me, especially at the price of admission. I personally would get more enjoyment out of owning the 3 pieces that you already have.

I don't know how hot the market is on that Sky-D reference as I don't follow it. If it's soft, would it be better to sell all 3 pieces at a premium, then negotiate a good deal on a Sky-D purchase directly?

They go for about $10k above retail but they don’t sell fast. It’s an acquired taste as you can see from the majority of comments!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[HogwldFLTR]

It's too large for me. So no.

[OrangeSport]

No

[Golfbone]

If you want the Sky D on OF I'd put an order in with an AD, sit back and wait and you will probably get one in time at list price. Brand new. Meanwhile the other pieces are gold bricks...money in the bank that will hold/increase in value and can be sold at any time. Green sub is worth 20+K, 2 tone sub 15-17, and red 43 Sea Dweller 17K. You already have a piece on Oyster flex and IMO a rubber band is ....well it's just rubber. No comparison in value to PM bracelet. So if the SD had a gold bracelet then we'd be talking but to trade 3 valuable pieces for a piece on rubber? No way. BTW I have a blue SD on jubilee and it's great but it's not a beater that's for sure. You don't want to wear it every day and bang up that gold bezel. The 3 pieces you have give you much more versatility and will not damage as easy. So you came on here asking for opinions and that one is mine but yours is the only one that matters right? I think that most people would say that if you make this deal ....looking back in 10 years you will probably wish you had not and in telling you that we are trying to help you.

[Jonnewbank]

Originally Posted by Golfbone

If you want the Sky D on OF I'd put an order in with an AD, sit back and wait and you will probably get one in time at list price. Brand new. Meanwhile the other pieces are gold bricks...money in the bank that will hold/increase in value and can be sold at any time. Green sub is worth 20+K, 2 tone sub 15-17, and red 43 Sea Dweller 17K. You already have a piece on Oyster flex and IMO a rubber band is ....well it's just rubber. No comparison in value to PM bracelet. So if the SD had a gold bracelet then we'd be talking but to trade 3 valuable pieces for a piece on rubber? No way. BTW I have a blue SD on jubilee and it's great but it's not a beater that's for sure. You don't want to wear it every day and bang up that gold bezel. The 3 pieces you have give you much more versatility and will not damage as easy. So you came on here asking for opinions and that one is mine but yours is the only one that matters right? I think that most people would say that if you make this deal ....looking back in 10 years you will probably wish you had not and in telling you that we are trying to help you.

Great response and that sounds very sensible! Unfortunately this isn’t a sensible hobby! Few mulled wines over Xmas to think it over! I will probably wait until
The price increase hits anyway as they are going up.

I’ve always liked rubber straps on watches. I don’t wear suits to work and they seem to be so much more comfortable. Adding the glidelock onto it has really got me interested. I also find the subs a touch small.
I am on the list and I have a very good relationship so I may just wait it out.

Thanks for the response and have a good Xmas!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[vipereaper30]

I'd do it in a heartbeat the Skydweller is so amazing!

However, my one recommendation would be to hold on to the LV if able. 1 steel, 2 PM collection would be perfect and give you a lot more versatility.

[Jonnewbank]

Originally Posted by vipereaper30

I'd do it in a heartbeat the Skydweller is so amazing!

However, my one recommendation would be to hold on to the LV if able. 1 steel, 2 PM collection would be perfect and give you a lot more versatility.

It’s my least favourite of the four weirdly! The ultimate hype watch for me. Find it quite petit and a bit boring.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[vipereaper30]

Originally Posted by Jonnewbank

It’s my least favourite of the four weirdly! The ultimate hype watch for me. Find it quite petit and a bit boring.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

In that case I'd go for it but keep the one steel that speaks the most to you. Skydweller in PM can be the pinnacle of any Rolex collection.

[10XRolex]

The Sub I would keep. The other two off them.

Sent from my SM-G975U1 using Tapatalk

[JodyHighroller]

I would, but I’d keep the LV.

[Jonnewbank]

Originally Posted by JodyHighroller

I would, but I’d keep the LV.

Have you worn one? I’ve got to say it’s very underwhelming. I took it because it was offered at retail but it’s quite boring.

From a value perspective sure!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[brandrea]

This would have been a good poll … NO

[Jonnewbank]

Originally Posted by brandrea

This would have been a good poll … NO

I think I know how it would have gone!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[brandrea]

Originally Posted by Jonnewbank

I think I know how it would have gone!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Sent from my SM-G960W using Tapatalk

[dba]

No. Not a Skydweller fan.

[Jonnewbank]

Originally Posted by dba

No. Not a Skydweller fan.

Sure?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[fskywalker]

hmmmmmm

No!!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[Solo118]

I would say keep the LV, swap the other 2 plus a little cash for the SKD. Perfect watch combo.

[dwjez14]

Crazy ! Heck no

[vipereaper30]

Call me a contrarian, it appears almost everyone is a no here but I still say DO IT!

Although this reference works way better on the bracelet for some reason it looks boxy on the oysterflex.

[russeree]

That would be a bold move Cotton.

[Jonnewbank]

Originally Posted by russeree

That would be a bold move Cotton.

Is that a dodgeball quote!? If so, awesome


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Bigmozza]

That Sky Dweller in that combination rose gold & slate dial on OF is absolutely gorgeous I would if it was me no problem, listen to what you’re heart tells you good luck mate

[Jonnewbank]

Originally Posted by Bigmozza

That Sky Dweller in that combination rose gold & slate dial on OF is absolutely gorgeous I would if it was me no problem, listen to what you’re heart tells you good luck mate

Always tell a uk lad with the use of mate!

Cheers pal. I’m debating it now with a glass of amarone.

I’m actually considering swapping the yachtmaster 42 and two tone for it now. Direct swap.

Keep the green sub and sd43


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[7enderbender]

Absolutely not. Can’t say that three watches you have would be my first choice (I don’t do cyclops or two-tone) but there is nothing about a sky dweller that beats three solid stainless steel Rolex. Not the most appealing design, size and precious metals are for storage in case of the apocalypse.

[Jonnewbank]

Plot thickens, we open our presents on Xmas eve and wife just pulled out a brand new air king for me from our dealer.

Not my favourite but probably one for the safe.

Merry Xmas everyone!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Bigmozza]

If it was my choice I’d swap the YM42 & the SD43 & keep the green sub & two tone, but I would definitely get the Sky Dweller as I said before it’s a stunning piece especially in that combination on another level, and not many will have one, good luck Happy Christmas & don’t forget to post some pic’s when you get it ha ha.

[Jonnewbank]

Originally Posted by Bigmozza

If it was my choice I’d swap the YM42 & the SD43 & keep the green sub & two tone, but I would definitely get the Sky Dweller as I said before it’s a stunning piece especially in that combination on another level, and not many will have one, good luck Happy Christmas & don’t forget to post some pic’s when you get it ha ha.

Will do mate! If I do it! Which is likely!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Jonnewbank]

Just to finish off this thread, went to try it on and as stunning as it is I didn’t really get what it’s for. It’s not dressy with the rubber and the fluted doesn’t make it sporty. Stunning but something that would need to be in a larger collection. One day.

I’m first on the list for a Daytona flex sundust so time to refocus


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk