Another...Is this trade crazy?

[Daytona2016]

My:

Black 116500 Daytona
BLRO Pepsi
126610LV Kermit

For:

WG GMT Meteorite

I’d still have my new white 116500 (checks the Daytona box), BLNR, and my Everose Yachtmaster.

I’m thinking this is a horrible idea but the other side of my brain really lusts for the Meterorite. My rationale...I like wearing the white dial Daytona better than the black so I can live without it, I don’t love the jubilee on the BLRO and will have the Meteorite to scratch the Pepsi itch, and I can live without the new Kermit.

Shoot me straight!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Atone]

that's insane. no.

By market rates, you're overpaying by about $8k give or take.

[Daytona2016]

Mods can close thread now - that’s all I needed


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[kpinthebay]

Yeah I see your thought process...but just sheer value to value alone you would be out of your mind. That meteorite though is pure sexy.

Sent from my Pixel 3 XL using Tapatalk

[TickTockChuck]

That seems like a lot to give up for one watch! I wasn't under the impression that the meteorite GMT was that difficult to get. You could probably get the meteorite from an AD in a reasonable time (?) and sell those fine watches you already have for more. Think about it carefully before you sell those 3 great watches you already have. You should at least try a meteorite on first to make sure it floats your boat. Good luck. Cheers!

[samuel019]

Oof! 3 for 1 is hard pass for me. Especially those 3.

[sgwatchguy]

Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad deal

[Harry-57]

Yes it's bonkers. A wonderful watch to own but not for that trade.

[BNA/LION]

Don't Do It.

[Daytona2016]

Thanks, all. Appreciate the thoughts / weigh-in. Pretty much as expected since the three SS pieces are so hard to come by and I was lucky enough to acquire all three at MSRP, too.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[BOXMAN76]

Hello no...Not unless your getting a ton of cash on top of the trade.

[Max 66]

If you look at the MSRP it will be a very good deal

Seriously, it is sufficient to sell the Black Daytona and the Pepsi and wait to get the GMT Meteorite from your AD (if you have all these Rolex you should also have a good relation with one or more ADs); with the collection that you have I will do this swap.

[Daytona2016]

Originally Posted by Max 66

If you look at the MSRP it will be a very good deal

Seriously, it is sufficient to sell the Black Daytona and the Pepsi and wait to get the GMT Meteorite from your AD (if you have all these Rolex you should also have a good relation with one or more ADs).

Your thinking here is exactly what I had in mind as another option. Thx!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[levvity]

No way I would do this.. stick with your 3!

[60sec]

Yep, crazy.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Daytona2016]

Originally Posted by levvity

No way I would do this.. stick with your 3!

I hear ya. The question is really more of what will I wear vs long term collectibility. Long term, I think these 3 stainless pieces likely outperform the meteorite but it’s tough to say...and I’d wear the meteorite whereas these 3 don’t get much rotation time on the wrist. First world problems!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Max 66]

Originally Posted by Daytona2016

Your thinking here is exactly what I had in mind as another option. Thx!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Indeed, you own the white dial Daytona and you like it more than the black one, so to keep also the black Daytona doesn't make any sense as well as to keep the Jubilee SS Pepsi if you will get the Meteorite Pepsi.
To the contrary it is always nice to get a Sub in the collection and the Kermit is gorgeous, so I would not sell it.

BTW, the WG Meteorite Pepsi is the best GMT ever, IMHO

[RJRJRJ]

If you're valuing the meteorite at market price, you have to value your lot the same way. Bad deal money wise as is, but if you can work a fair deal I might actually consider it.

[time_and_cars]

Originally Posted by Daytona2016

My:

Black 116500 Daytona
BLRO Pepsi
126610LV Kermit

For:

WG GMT Meteorite

I’d still have my new white 116500 (checks the Daytona box), BLNR, and my Everose Yachtmaster.

I’m thinking this is a horrible idea but the other side of my brain really lusts for the Meterorite. My rationale...I like wearing the white dial Daytona better than the black so I can live without it, I don’t love the jubilee on the BLRO and will have the Meteorite to scratch the Pepsi itch, and I can live without the new Kermit.

Shoot me straight!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

One month ago I have the opportunity to see the WG GMT meteorite in the flesh ...... the watch looks amazing from another world .... for me it’s a insane trade but the gmt looks amazing

[RolexSimon]

I don't think the value has to be compared at MRP. Even if you use grey prices, you're paying approx $10K too much. Just remember the WG Pepsi will scratch more and you might think you'll give it more wrist time but I'd imagine, like me, once the initial buzz wears off, you'll use it for dinners and special occassions - maybe one a week or so.

[rolexfanforlife]

The meteorite is worth it. I know it’s a lot to give up, but trust me, it’s incredible. Maybe sell two, keep sub and add cash?

[dwjez14]

Heck. No

[kieselguhr]

You’re out of your mind if you proceed with this. Well, that’s what I would tell myself

[brandrea]

Not a snowballs chance ...

[7sins]

Originally Posted by rolexfanforlife

The meteorite is worth it. I know it’s a lot to give up, but trust me, it’s incredible. Maybe sell two, keep sub and add cash?

This +100

[Dougiebaby]

Originally Posted by Daytona2016

My:

Black 116500 Daytona
BLRO Pepsi
126610LV Kermit

For:

WG GMT Meteorite

I’d still have my new white 116500 (checks the Daytona box), BLNR, and my Everose Yachtmaster.

I’m thinking this is a horrible idea but the other side of my brain really lusts for the Meterorite. My rationale...I like wearing the white dial Daytona better than the black so I can live without it, I don’t love the jubilee on the BLRO and will have the Meteorite to scratch the Pepsi itch, and I can live without the new Kermit.

Shoot me straight!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

An interesting observation ... the three in question as a trio is, quite literally, a perfect collection of Rolexes.

Land Sea Air. Arguably, the three hardest to get pieces (yes I know white dial Daytona and blue Skydweller yadda yadda yadda). A perfect symphony of bracelets: jubilee + brushed oyster + PCL oyster. Travel, Chrono, and swim. And the list goes on.

However...

When taking your other watches into account, I don’t have a problem with the trade as long as you ALSO get some cash in the deal.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[amilch]

As much I like the WG GMT Meteorite, I wouldn't do it.

[Nikrnic]

That is a horrible idea.. Stop listening to the other side of your brain..

Sent from my SM-G970U using Tapatalk

[Daytona2016]

Originally Posted by Dougiebaby

An interesting observation ... the three in question as a trio is, quite literally, a perfect collection of Rolexes.

Land Sea Air. Arguably, the three hardest to get pieces (yes I know white dial Daytona and blue Skydweller yadda yadda yadda). A perfect symphony of bracelets: jubilee + brushed oyster + PCL oyster. Travel, Chrono, and swim. And the list goes on.

However...

When taking your other watches into account, I don’t have a problem with the trade as long as you ALSO get some cash in the deal.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Tough call, right?

[Daytona2016]

Originally Posted by RolexSimon

I don't think the value has to be compared at MRP. Even if you use grey prices, you're paying approx $10K too much. Just remember the WG Pepsi will scratch more and you might think you'll give it more wrist time but I'd imagine, like me, once the initial buzz wears off, you'll use it for dinners and special occassions - maybe one a week or so.

Great perspective, appreciate it!