Which SS watch should I get?

[douglasf13]

Originally Posted by fmacken

AP all the way. Aquanaut and BLNR aren't in the same league with the RO


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

A $20K Patek isn't in the same league as a $17K AP?

[Power Play]

I'm a Rolex guy at least 5 days per week but, given the options, I'd be all over the 5167. In fact, I acquired the 5176 (on the rare bracelet) and wear it when the occasion calls for something just a bit more special than a Rolex tool watch.

Something about the 5167 just absolutely speaks to me and the workmanship and visible movement are nothing short of breathtaking. I get a 'buzz' every time I wear it.

The AP's, on the other hand, don't really do it for me. I bought one for the Mrs and she mildly enjoyed it for a year or so; since there was no real connection we flipped it for a JLC Master Geographic (also on bracelet) which she much prefers.

Just our humble opinions; enjoy the hunt!

[AK797]

Originally Posted by watchdoc123

I have the blue YM, TT sub, Hulk and a Presidential Day/Date. I tried on the aquanaut and the BLNR and they were both amazing. Never tried that Royal Oak. I know this is a Rolex site but I also know there is a PP and AP forum as well here. I thought someone might own 2 or even all 3 of the ones in question and give me their thoughts.

Yes, I thought you had a few of these, think you are heavy on Rolex so I'd pick the Aquanaut. I love the blue 15400 but you might be covered for blue as well if you have 2 already.

[RolexNorth]

I hear the AP's are a b##$ch to service and costly. $3500 for typical service.

[pablo5]

Originally Posted by watchdoc123

I have the blue YM, TT sub, Hulk and a Presidential Day/Date. I tried on the aquanaut and the BLNR and they were both amazing. Never tried that Royal Oak. I know this is a Rolex site but I also know there is a PP and AP forum as well here. I thought someone might own 2 or even all 3 of the ones in question and give me their thoughts.

Considering your collection above I'd definitely have a look at the AP ROO. I absolutely love the integrated bracelet and quality of AP. You already have 3 Rolex sport watches so it wouldn't be a bad idea to diversify with another iconic piece. The 39mm ROO thin is a great option if you're not a fan of 42mm. I might be in the minority but for a high end steel sports watch I'd rather go AP than Patek. I've had the Nautilus and maybe for my size and stature (6 ft/200lbs) I just prefer a little bit more of a substantial watch and bracelet which the AP is for me. I would choose Patek when it comes to dress watches any day of the week though.

[douglasf13]

Originally Posted by RolexNorth

I hear the AP's are a b##$ch to service and costly. $3500 for typical service.

https://www.fratellowatches.com/serv...ervice-prices/

[pablo5]

Originally Posted by douglasf13

https://www.fratellowatches.com/serv...ervice-prices/

Full service on my AP was $800 and took about 12 weeks.

[Juantxo]

When I buy a car, or a watch or so many other things, I always consider after-sale service. After-sale service accounts for some good 50% of my decision.

That said, in your case, I'd take PP right off the list. AP has rather decent service, and Rolex service is a bit better. Between AP and Rolex, I'm way over fashion and niceties, and prefer solid, reliable, durable watches... and in that realm Rolex is king. Just my $0.02.

[dnpina]

Patek. If I could, I would. That's the one. Gorgeous. Good luck

[Mikegp]

I'd go 5167. Had an AP 15202 and never really bonded with it. Sold it. The 5167 is my favorite watch right now. I also own a subc, Daytona Ceramic and a Nautilus 5711.

The BLNR has nothing on the Aquanaut. Not even a close call


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro

[arguetaoscar]

Just saw a BLNR at my AD the other day. So tempted


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[NoVaSubowner]

Originally Posted by GMTMasterDallas

It really depends on what's already in your collection. In my opinion the Aquanaut is slightly toy-like, and some would argue slightly feminine compared to a Nautilus (Like an Audi TT vs the R8, or the Mercedes SLK vs the SL). It's also priced a little too high imo, and it doesn't give you much. Both the BLNR and RO are great watches. I own the BLNR and love it, but it really depends on what other watches you currently have. I'd rank the RO a little bit ahead of the BLNR, because I love the RO bracelet, but it's your call.

"Toy like?" "Feminine?" Thanks... I'll make sure I pair some heels, and a boa and feathers when I put my Aquanaut on tomorrow morning full of regret that I didn't get much for my money as well as envious desire for a Nautilus or RO.......

[Investr]

Originally Posted by lecorsaire

The 15400st but only with the blue dial!!! That is the one to get. Otherwise BLNR. Not into the Aquanaut really. Yes it's a PP but so what?

perfect answer!!!

[DeeTee]

No reason for the BLNR.

15400 is my pick out the bunch.

[vladamir15]

Blnr

[And1dre]

BLNR for me!

[PrinceT]

I vote 15400


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Hank]

The Aquanaut is super comfortable and discreet. The BLNR is a great daily wearer and very versatile. The AP is the most special among the three IMHO. It really comes down to what you want and what other watches you have in your collection.

[Z3ke]

fellow doc I work with owns the ro 15400. certainly holds up better than the jumbo and has a larger power reserve. certainly imo not as bulky on the wrist if a 40mm sub or gmt fits you nicely. He wears it everyday and Ive seen it up close, not much scratches. Depends what you want. if you like a high horology piece in ss thats good for daily wear youll be happy with the ro. aquanaut is not my taste as I prefer the 5711, but that would be a better daily wearer than the ro; however ro imo has the better look and feel (Ive tried these watches on before).

GMT cant go wrong as a daily wear, certainly would cost less to service overtime. GMT would be nice to add to the collection but having the RO or aquanaut would certainly round out your collection, not to mention owning a high horology piece.

try on the watches and just go with what you want and what makes you happy.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Gob Bluth]

I know it's not one of the 3 options but I'd go AP 15202 then aquanaut (on green rubber) then BLNR.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[AMG RICH]

I own both Batman and PP 5167-1A I liked the PP but it got old to me real quick.Batman is a watch that at any angle you look at it it sings.

[brandrea]

If you need the GMT function then the choice is obvious. If not, the 5167 would be my choice.

[Andad]

Don't let the BLNR hype get to you, it is really just an SS GMTc with a different bezel insert.

Try them all on and choose the one you want to KEEP.

E.

[AK797]

Originally Posted by GMTMasterDallas

It really depends on what's already in your collection. In my opinion the Aquanaut is slightly toy-like, and some would argue slightly feminine compared to a Nautilus (Like an Audi TT vs the R8, or the Mercedes SLK vs the SL). It's also priced a little too high imo, and it doesn't give you much. Both the BLNR and RO are great watches. I own the BLNR and love it, but it really depends on what other watches you currently have. I'd rank the RO a little bit ahead of the BLNR, because I love the RO bracelet, but it's your call.

Feminine? It's wearing a big rubber strap, can't get more masculine than that.