Removing the Cyclops?

[JohnFM]

Thanks to Patrick Aziz (with generous input from George Ab, Tony Geha, and David SW), I own a 16610 Submariner and 16600 Sea Dweller -- both great watches and all reputable sellers!

I prefer the trimmer profile and larger face of the Submariner but love the clean, flat, no-cyclops dial of the Sea Dweller. So ... I was thinking of having the cyclops removed from the 16610.

I spoke with a couple of watchmakers today in northern California and am thoroughly confused! Other than the fact that most of all of them told me not to do it, prices ranged from $100 to $250. One said he'd add a little chemical (acetone?) next to the cyclops to dissolve a small portion of the glue, then chip the crystal off, and then clean and re-install the crystal. Another said it's best to remove the crystal, heat it with a torch, melt the glue, remove the cyclops, and clean and re-install the crystal. Another said it's best to simply remove the old crystal and put a new one on, sans cyclops, but that the crystal would have to be after-market sapphire since all of the Rolex crystals that would fit the 16610 include a cyclops.

Suggestions and input are appreciated.
Thanks.
John