Platinum VS. White Gold

[armen34]

Originally Posted by T01

Platinum is more of a brilliant white where as WG has a yellowish huge to it when compared. Both are amazing, however you cannot beat Platinum.

[Jeffreyc87]

Originally Posted by directioneng

Umm...ok.



That would be no.

Apologies. Bad spelling and grammar and word choice. It takes much more pt950 allot to make a particular Rolex model than its 18 kt gold counterpart.

Yes, an ounce of pure gold may cost more than an ounce of platinum but a platinum DD2 would weigh maybe 220 vs the DD2 in gold would weigh maybe
140.

[Jeffreyc87]

Originally Posted by Umbongo

What is this "pt gold" you speak of?

Meant 18kt gold vs 950pt or platinum.

It takes more ounces of pt to make a Rolex Daytona vs an 18kt daytona because pt is denser than gold.

[dkg1616]

I would also check into what type of deal you can get from your AD!!! Especially if you have a strong relationship!

[tulowitzki]

I don’t know an AD. I’d rather buy pre-owned as well to save some money. Anyone have any feedback on buying off eBay?

[pfg1]

I recommend platinum .......

A platinum Rolex will look darn near new after a few years of wear with a monthly maintenance/cleaning routine using WristClean spray.....no need for professional polishing or buffing.

A YGold or WGold Rolex takes on a dull finish (or patina) after a few years....even with regular cleanings.....gold also scratches quite easily.

You can spot a platinum Rolex “in the wild” from 50ft away.....and they are rare versus the classic yellow gold Rolex models that are much more common.

One feature of a modern platinum Rolex that I do not care for is the smooth bezel....BUT......it is also the one unique feature that is a dead giveaway because I believe all (or nearly all) WG/YG Rolexes have fluted bezels.

The second unique feature of a modern platinum Rolex: light “ice blue” dials. I really like the diagonal motif on the DD40 228206.

Be Well,
Pfg1

[tulowitzki]

Originally Posted by dkg1616

I would also check into what type of deal you can get from your AD!!! Especially if you have a strong relationship!

I don’t have an AD. Been looking strictly online. A guy with 2,000 positive feedbacks has to be legit right? I’m looking for pre-owned only.

[Muxi]

As mentioned above, there was a time in recent past when Plat was much more expensive than gold, also the time when Plat was released by Rolex as a PM. Thus, recent commodity price reversal could not be factored in anymore. Only time will tell if it will, at least in pre-owned resale prices. I like both Plat and WG being stealth wealth.

[Rolex Essex]

There’s a photo somewhere that a platona weights TWICE as much as a Daytona C.

[tkerrmd]

Originally Posted by The Nail Tech

There’s a photo somewhere that a platona weights TWICE as much as a Daytona C.

Platona is the heaviest Rolex

[nyc2la]

Go platinum if you can. Nothing like it.

[benlee]

Originally Posted by nyc2la

Go platinum if you can. Nothing like it.

This looks amazing.

[VICI]

WG looks more yellow than the PT.

PT is also much heavier.

You can find better deals on a PT DDII if you look.

Honestly, the PT premium is ridiculous.

[returntorolex]

Originally Posted by Jeffreyc87

Apologies. Bad spelling and grammar and word choice. It takes much more pt950 allot to make a particular Rolex model than its 18 kt gold counterpart.

Yes, an ounce of pure gold may cost more than an ounce of platinum but a platinum DD2 would weigh maybe 220 vs the DD2 in gold would weigh maybe
140.

The 36mm Pt DD weighs 227 grams. The DD2 in Pt would be heavier - closer to 275+ grams.

The 36mm WG DD weighs 179 grams for reference.

[zama]

I have both as others have said, Platinum is noticeably heavier, depending on whether you see that as good or bad (both are much heavier than SS), the platinum certainly has more shine/glimmer (see photo of my DD in partial light) where WG is more dull and softer sheen, the platinum is more rare, again as others have said it comes with unique elements that only come to that model, smooth bezel, dials etc. Both are good, buy what you like, as many will tell you gold price is higher, but platinum in rolex is pure, and apparently platinum is harder to work which in part is why it is their premium product. Both hold up well to daily living.

Second hand does equalise out better the up front price differential.

[lecorsaire]

Originally Posted by tulowitzki

Hello, this is my first time posting so go easy on me please.

Ive been looking at WG Day Date2 and the current pre-owned market is around 29k to 32k

On the other hand I've seen the Platinum DD2 pre-owned and its 41k to 44k.

I have never tried on the platinum but I have the WG. They look very similar in color and I don't understand the huge difference in price?

2nd part of my question.... A new WG day date 2 retails for 37k. Pre-owned 29k. thats an 8k difference.

Platinum Day Date 2 retails for 57k and pre- owned 41k. 16k difference.

Why is there such a big swing in pricing for these two watches?

Thans in advance for the help.

Even though in recent times the Pt spot has been cheaper or on par with Au, traditionally it was always the other way around. It has always been the most luxurious precious metal used in jewelry. It is much rarer and harder to work with. It is also by far the preferred metal for engagement rings as well.

I also believe that machining platinum wears out the tools much faster than gold which is soft but really there is a $20k+ premium just because it’s Pt. It also is purer than gold in jewelry. 950 vs 750 so more of the weight is PM than 18kt gold which has to be blended with platinum, palladium or rhodium in contrast with 5% of rhodium, silver or another similar metal. Not every piece of PM jewelry uses the same blend. For example, Rolex has a special blend to make their Everose gold in house which tends to keep its hue longer than other rose/pink gold.

So that’s pretty much why there is this substantial difference. I personally believe PT is worth the money. There really is nothing like it. I love its extra heft.

[tulowitzki]

Originally Posted by VICI

WG looks more yellow than the PT.

PT is also much heavier.

You can find better deals on a PT DDII if you look.

Honestly, the PT premium is ridiculous.

Excuse me not knowing but what is PT DDII?

[VICI]

Originally Posted by tulowitzki

Excuse me not knowing but what is PT DDII?

Platinum Day Date 2 - 41 mm

[tulowitzki]

Oh I should know that! Thanks

[Mattewlaird]

They are both worth their values.

[G.D.BeanCounter]

I have owned both, Platinum and WG DD2s. The platinum was always the end game, and when the opportunity arose, the WG was on the chopping block. I echo what others have said, if money is not a deciding factor, platinum wins by a long shot. Just my 2 cents. Best of wishes on whichever you decide.

[watchwatcher]

My advice. Look for the watch that appeals to you and that you're smitten with. And get that one.

If you start worrying about why one metal is more expensive than another...and then everyone is going to chime in with the watch you should get...you quickly lose the fun out of the whole thing, IMO.

[tulowitzki]

Originally Posted by watchwatcher

My advice. Look for the watch that appeals to you and that you're smitten with. And get that one.

If you start worrying about why one metal is more expensive than another...and then everyone is going to chime in with the watch you should get...you quickly lose the fun out of the whole thing, IMO.

I appreciate that advice and all of the other advice. For me at the end of the day I've learned a bunch about why platinum is the more expensive material and I think from what I've heard its the way I want to go.

My next dilemma is finding one! Hard to trust a guy whom I've never met who's selling the watch on eBay. Gonna give it a go on Thursday.

[tulowitzki]

They both appeal to me thats why I was asking for some opinions. Ive never educated myself in platinum. I feel like I have heard enough to feel comfortable taking the plunge at that premium price. Now I have to actually find one. The search is on.

[JeffreyD]

Platinum is of higher value than white gold in terms of precious metal value. The hardness and hence scratch resistance depends on the specific alloy of each material. I am not familiar with the ROLEX alloys, although I do know that the WG is 18k. It may or may not be harder than the Pt. The Pt alloy with remain "whiter" over time. 18k WG is alloyed with Palladium and silver, which can wear off over time, appearing "yellower".

Pt is definitely worth more than WG. If you can afford it, go with Pt.

[JeffreyD]

Magnificent!

[rolexpatek363]

Originally Posted by AK797

Why the difference in price? Because WG looks yellowish, Plat looks just like SS.

Platinum has a silvery-grey sheen to it, compared with stainless steel, which looks whiter.

I vote for platinum all day. Relatively discreet with the domed bezel. A 36 mm Platinum Day-Date weighs nearly half a pound.

[MCO1]

Platinum all the way! Besides it's the only metal that you can get that beautiful ice blue dial with.

[tulowitzki]

What’s a good price for dd2 pt? Used not new.

[TimeToWatch]

Originally Posted by JeffreyD

Platinum is of higher value than white gold in terms of precious metal value. The hardness and hence scratch resistance depends on the specific alloy of each material. I am not familiar with the ROLEX alloys, although I do know that the WG is 18k. It may or may not be harder than the Pt. The Pt alloy with remain "whiter" over time. 18k WG is alloyed with Palladium and silver, which can wear off over time, appearing "yellower".

Pt is definitely worth more than WG. If you can afford it, go with Pt.

Gold is actually more valuable than Pt at the moment - $1,314 vs $916/oz. Yes Pt watches are more pure than 18 kt gold, but that wouldn't expain the price difference between WG and Pt. It's simply Rolex's marketing and brand positioning - platinum has always been their most precious metal, used on their most prestigious watches.

Of the metals Rolex employees, Pt is hardest, followed by SS and then gold. Rolex uses 18 kt gold, because anything finer would be way too soft.

One thing that's great about Rolex's WG is it lacks a rhodium plating like many other WG alloys. As a result, it remains nice and white throughout its lifetime, without losing luster or yellowing.