james cameron or 43mm sea dweller

[golfski]

DSSD JC all the way. I originally wanted the SD43 but got the JC and have had for 6 months. Recently my number came up on the SS43 and it did nothing for me, it looks like every other sub out there. The JC DSSD is more unique in the lineup and I prefer the heft of it over the slimmer SD43 and the bulging case back.

[Rori]

I agree on every word.

Originally Posted by superpop

I went with the SD43, looked at the JC and did not like all of the busyness of it. The ring lock text and all of the other text made it seem noisy to me. I could see it becoming dated fast. Plus it is a BIG watch. SD43 is the true modern interpretation of the rolex diver. And my older eyes appreciate the cyclops.

[Dimaxxxl]

I think whether you like the cyclops or not also plays a roll in that decision.

[thekman]

Would say it depends on your wrist. I could not pull of the deepsea when I tried it on but the SD43 fit nicely.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Roli4life]

SD43 MK1. Because it’s more collectible, and aesthetically perfect.
The JC Is just too fat.

[DaninFlorida]

Originally Posted by garyk

The James Cameron because it’s one of if not the only time in Rolex history they created a commemorative watch for a specific person/event. Extremely unique, wears so well for a big watch and is beautiful to look at imo...

Unfortunately for me, thats a deal breaker. Not a fan of James Cameron ever since i watched the titantic special he did where they tried to reconstruct how the titanic came to be laying on sea floor in the way that it is. They had a very qualified engineer that kept telling him his "theory" was nonsense and provided the math and backup to prove him wrong. the great JC's response...he was fired and gone. and JC declared his theory was correct.

to have a highly technical watch named after him doesnt sit well with the engineer in me.

[Jona]

Maybe then it will be worth millions if it commemorates a poor engineer.

[Gerry62]

[brandrea]

Originally Posted by Roli4life

SD43 MK1. Because it’s more collectible, and aesthetically perfect.
The JC Is just too fat.

That is one of the best pictures of this reference I’ve seen outside of Rolex

[brandrea]

OP, this would’ve made an interesting poll thread.

Regardless, there will be those who make extremely valid case points for both references. I’ve owned both at the same time and the SD43 remains. For me it’s the better wearing watch, more versatile and I love the nod to its older brother in Rolex history.

Good luck deciding

[harvey]

SD43 mk1 and JC2...either way you will be happy!




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[samson66]

If you are ok with the thickness, the DSSD. If you want something a little more wearable the SD43

[MichelleP]

JC DSSD because the dial is one of the best Rolex makes.

[-Ally-]

Sd43.

[Dirt]

Originally Posted by SS Oyster

Go for the most technically advanced diver. It wears better with a flush back - SD43 caseback protrudes excessively from the case, which can cause discomfort.

Plus, the DSSD just stands out. Can’t be mistaken for a Sub date.

I owned SD43 first and sold it once I bought DSSD D-Blue as I knew it would no longer get wrist time.








Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Good points
Also Brian makes an important observation that can't be ignored in that wrist shape is equally important.

The OP makes no reference to their wrist size or shape so the best advice I can offer is to try both on and see for himself. The old school way

[alphadweller]

They're both terrific watches but there are a few things in the JC I'm not a fan of. Two years back I chose the SD43 and I'm glad I did, it felt perfect at the time and still does. No wrong choice though, only a matter of taste and comfort on your own wrist.

[Sublovin]

Classic! Domed crystal, greatest depth rating ever by a Rolex, Titanium back, huge crown, matte dial, no cyclops, what’s not to like!
In a sea of 40mm sport watches that all look the same with just different dials and bezels, this is in a class of its own!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Hollie_Rollie]

I vote SD43, I’m bias though

[Dirt]

Originally Posted by DaninFlorida

Unfortunately for me, thats a deal breaker. Not a fan of James Cameron ever since i watched the titantic special he did where they tried to reconstruct how the titanic came to be laying on sea floor in the way that it is. They had a very qualified engineer that kept telling him his "theory" was nonsense and provided the math and backup to prove him wrong. the great JC's response...he was fired and gone. and JC declared his theory was correct.

to have a highly technical watch named after him doesnt sit well with the engineer in me.

Whether one likes JC or not for what ever reason is irrelevant in this case because the watch is not actually named after the man.
It's merely a name applied to the watch in the same manner as the Paul Neuman, Steve McQueen and Marlon Brando.
Other names such as Kermit, Smurf, Hulk, Pepsi, Coke, Root Beer, Daytona, Bluesy, Snowflake, Blue Snowflake, Moonwatch etc are in another category but the intent is the same. It's better than quoting reference numbers, especially the Omega variety

[Dirt]

Originally Posted by Sublovin

Classic! Domed crystal, greatest depth rating ever by a Rolex, Titanium back, huge crown, matte dial, no cyclops, what’s not to like!
In a sea of 40mm sport watches that all look the same with just different dials and bezels, this is in a class of its own!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Agreed
Not to mention the exclusive use of the highest specification Glidelock style clasp which is unlikely to be equaled at any time in the future in the entire industry.

If only Rolex were able to see their way clear to make the DSSD exclusively out of Titanium right from the very start
I reckon that would've blown every aspect of the entire watch industry wide apart.
Imagine the headlines

Then again, the sphere of JC's submersible was made of SS so that connection probably has sufficient legitimacy besides the bright Kawasaki green

[LigerBelair]

Originally Posted by rom

the SD43 proportions are perfection, total harmony of all parts

Agreed and that's why I own a SD43.

[Sublovin]

Originally Posted by Dirt

Agreed

Not to mention the exclusive use of the highest specification Glidelock style clasp which is unlikely to be equaled at any time in the future in the entire industry.



If only Rolex were able to see their way clear to make the DSSD exclusively out of Titanium right from the very start

I reckon that would've blown every aspect of the entire watch industry wide apart.

Imagine the headlines



Then again, the sphere of JC's submersible was made of SS so that connection probably has sufficient legitimacy besides the bright Kawasaki green

Yep! I had the 43 and sold it. It’s nice, but it just felt like a jumbo Sub. The DSSD has so many Unique qualities, it’s just a lot of fun to wear and I never get tired of looking at it!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[javier]

43mm sea dweller. Better to resale

[tgyberg]

I love'm both. I went with the blue dial because I already have a couple of black dialed divers. Still not an easy decision however

[klenboy]

Defnitely the Deepsea!

[Kiddodoc]

Own all 3 ceramic subs, the SD 43 and the JC and they are awesome but I feel that the SD43 is the best all around Rolex diver. The DSSD is a beast but do I love it! Get both!!!

[Rrpdc]

Originally Posted by rtmelloy

43 because the James Cameron sticks out too much and appears smaller than the 43


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

+1

[Rrpdc]

Originally Posted by LigerBelair

Agreed and that's why I own a SD43.

+1. Jc is way to big. Sd43 is perfect.

[SS Oyster]

Here they are together, along with 16600 Sea Dweller




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Bbp]

Buy the one that sings to u... i love sd43 being the 50th anniversary with the single red line. I am biased.