Opinion on aqua terra vs. BB58

[Df1kilo1]

Man tough comparison because they’re so different. I have the black AT traditional bracelet and love it! Pairing with with Sub 124060 (arriving any day now fingers crossed). So I vote AT. And for what’s as worth as a total newbie I think 90% of Rolex die hards would still say Omega is great watch

[outlaw468]

Originally Posted by stevestil

Thank you everyone for your feedback! I enjoyed reading every single one.

I guess the only logical option here is buying the BB58 and keeping the AT as well….


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[fskywalker]

BB58 would be my pick


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[Justindo]

Given your collection, I'd definitely keep the Omega. It works great on a bracelet, leather, or rubber and is a higher quality watch than Tudor. It's also better for a one and done watch. If you didn't have a diver, I'd probably go for the BB58 but you do so why bother with the Tudor?

[Nodzex]

Originally Posted by dpt.calvin

Keep the Omega.

I agree!

[Nodzex]

Originally Posted by outlaw468

If money is not a problem then yes, keep AT and get BB.

[Krash]

Originally Posted by Df1kilo1

Man tough comparison because they’re so different. I have the black AT traditional bracelet and love it! Pairing with with Sub 124060 (arriving any day now fingers crossed). So I vote AT. And for what’s as worth as a total newbie I think 90% of Rolex die hards would still say Omega is great watch

Omega gets a lot of love on TRF.

Especially the Speedmaster, Seamaster divers and ATs.

Definitely more than Tudor…

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Rolexfan23]

I’d keep that omega. Very beautiful watch, I would have one myself but I just don’t care for the clasp they use.

[Lew Archer]

Originally Posted by stevestil

Thank you everyone for your feedback! I enjoyed reading every single one.

I guess the only logical option here is buying the BB58 and keeping the AT as well….


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

By George, I think he’s got it!

I have a Black Bay Blue 58 and a blue dial Aqua Terra, the “Skyfall” reference. Very different watches, glad to have both. The AT hovers between dress watch and sports watch, much like a Datejust. The Black Bay is an old school style dive watch. Good strap options with both. I wear the AT on an Omega dark blue leather strap, with deployment clasp, the Tudor on their blue NATO style strap.

I may go back to the Omega bracelet, and the Tudor “soft touch” fabric strap, but not anytime soon.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[1William]

I have owned several BB 58's and they are fine watches. I have never owned the AT but have always liked them and the photograph of yours is especially nice. I know you have already said just add the BB 58 but I might pause and look at other options. I am a huge Seiko fan and the SPB149 is a cool blue option at about $1400 that might just check the blocks that the BB 58 does. It is a retro inspired dive watch on a bracelet and I believe it comes with a strap also. Wears great and will not break the bank. The resale value is also high as it is a LE piece. Just a thought. Good luck.

[One Ping Only]

Originally Posted by stevestil

Thank you everyone for your feedback! I enjoyed reading every single one.

I guess the only logical option here is buying the BB58 and keeping the AT as well….

Sound logic, and usually the best answer- get both!

[BNA/LION]

Originally Posted by one ping only

sound logic, and usually the best answer- get both!

x2

[wrxdev]

Keep both. Both are great watches in their own regard.

[Watcheroo]

Originally Posted by stevestil

Thank you everyone for your feedback! I enjoyed reading every single one.

I guess the only logical option here is buying the BB58 and keeping the AT as well….


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Clearly…

:)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[holdingon]

If you get a 20% discount without tax on the Omega AT it's a better buy than the 58 at retail with tax. I picked up a nice AT 4.5k USD with blue dial. Good luck both nice watches.

[GradyPhilpott]

I'd stick with that Omega AT.

That's almost a no-brainer.

[DoctorA]

I’d choose omega over Tudor. Plus you already have a sub which makes the BB somewhat redundant and inferior to your sub

[3HandsNoDate]

Had both. Loved both. Omega probably slight edge on quality. Tudor a little cooler.

I’d probably take the AT, but just be patient and have both eventually. Trading one for the other will just cost you money anyway.

[stevestil]

Thanks everyone for your help and your opinions.

I’m going to Stick with the AT for now. Went by my AD yesterday and tried on a bb58 (they only had one on a leather strap).

Great watch and I plan on adding it to the collection eventually but I didn’t like it more than my AT


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Will16]

AT is a great watch. I agree… get both :)

[NativeTxn]

I have a Tudor Black Bay and had an Aqua Terra. Sold the Aqua Terra, but would have no issue picking one up again in the future.

If I hadn’t bought the Tudor to commemorate the birth of my second child, and didn’t have her name and birthdate engraved on the case back, I very likely would have sold it already.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[RFC]

Owning Subs and an AT I would keep the AT for its versatility as a daily watch including having a date.