New Pepsi vs Older Pepsi

[Frank McKay]

Not a fan of the old tuna can clasps. Modern bracelet/clasps are far more robust and richer feeling. No comparison in that regard.

[Nikrnic]

I feel the crazy and frienzied prices on the older versions compared to the quality of new ones cannot be justified to me. With all of the upgrades on the six digit models l can't go back. The bracelet alone is a deal breaker for me. Although lovely in their own right and knowing prices are relevant l felt better choosing a new Blnr over an old pepsi and kept 2 to 3k in my pocket.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

[rouxeny]

Love the colors of my 5 digit, but the flimsy feeling bracelet and laughably small crown detract from it in my eyes.

I think a super jub would help greatly.

[4vCoupe]

I can’t comment on the new Pepsi since I’ve never seen it in person (only WG version). 16750 matte dial with faded bezel is a classic.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[Brewersbrunch]

The richer colors of the old one are really hard to disagree with, but I lean toward the new one because that watch just looks SO good on the jubilee.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[iVAMP]

I really like the Pepsi Jubilee more than the former model.

I think that Jubilee bracelet fits better than the Oyster one.

[SeaAndSky]

Eric, that's a really nice collection of BLROs you have! It's nice to see them all side by side. Thanks for posting that. Cheers.

[s_haverford]

I personally can not do the new one. I am definitely going to be on the hunt for a vintage one when the time comes.

[kneedeep]

To me they are both comfortable, the new BLRO on Super Jubilee a little more so.

[10klakes]

Love them both...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Chilly Coconut]

Originally Posted by 10klakes

Love them both...

It’s really interesting how different the colors on this 126710 look from the colors on the one in the OP, while the colors on the two 16710s look pretty much the same.

[SVH]

there's so much to like about both, but they're like two totally different watches except for the GMT function.

I was ambivalent to the new pepsi and biased to the 16750. After trying it on, it's hard for the photos to do it justice. and the 16750 bracelet feels lighter and frequently chimes/rattles vs the solid link silence.

still love the 16750, if an AD in the area had a new one i'd probably get it,too

[10klakes]

Originally Posted by Chilly Coconut

It’s really interesting how different the colors on this 126710 look from the colors on the one in the OP, while the colors on the two 16710s look pretty much the same.

The 126710 bezel changes colors. It’s unlike the BLNR or any other cerachrome I own. It’s almost iridescent....


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[VicLeChic]

I prefer the lugs and colours of the old Pepsi. Having said that, faced with the choice I'd still go for the new one for several reasons (benefits of the new movement, bracelet and clasp, warranty, serviceability).

[Bagman]

Originally Posted by DtownRRS

Great set!



I will see your 20yr old and raise you 10! 16750 circa 1988. I do like the new BLRO but nothing will replace my original GMT.

Agreed



Richard B.
#16013 datejust, #216580 Explorer 2 (PVD’d), #16710 Pepsi#218238 yg President, #116610LV Hulk, #126600 Sea dweller

[Bagman]

Originally Posted by Soarer

That'll be hilarious as people start dumping the BLRO. I think Rolex is still a few years away from getting the "true color" Pepsi to fruition.

Sent from my SM-G950W using Tapatalk

That “correction” would make mine worth more.



Richard B.
#16013 datejust, #216580 Explorer 2 (PVD’d), #16710 Pepsi#218238 yg President, #116610LV Hulk, #126600 Sea dweller

[Bagman]

Originally Posted by Swearengen

Love em all

Nice collection



Richard B.
#16013 datejust, #216580 Explorer 2 (PVD’d), #16710 Pepsi#218238 yg President, #116610LV Hulk, #126600 Sea dweller

[Bagman]

Originally Posted by nyc2la

Great picture to compare. Thanks!

Both are fantastic. Personally, I prefer (and have) the new one, but I’d love to have both.

Wear and enjoy both of those beauties!

Richard B.
#16013 datejust, #216580 Explorer 2 (PVD’d), #16710 Pepsi#218238 yg President, #116610LV Hulk, #126600 Sea dweller

[codecow]

Originally Posted by Frank McKay

Not a fan of the old tuna can clasps. Modern bracelet/clasps are far more robust and richer feeling. No comparison in that regard.

Hahah that's true they are like a tuna can.

My $0.02 cents on this (have a Coke bezel 16710 and the new Pepsi) one thing people are forgetting are the hands and the lume on the newer GMTs. Having the big hands makes the watch easier to read.

To be honest I thought the new Pepsi's colors would be brighter. When I picked mine up in the store my wife couldn't even make out the blue and thought it looked like a Coke bezel.

[travisb]

Nice pic and a great pair to have. If I ever go back to a 5 digit, it'll be a 16710.

[mineral]

Love the five digits Gmt




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[jlovda]

Originally Posted by Bagman

I posted a picture last week of new Pepsi.
Thought you’d want to see the difference in the colors. The fact that one of them is approaching 20yrs old & the others bezel is ceramic may have something to do with it.

Beautiful shot!!

I have a question. I own a Pepsi 1675 from 1974. How does the size of my watch compare with your older Pepsi? I'm lusting over the new model and want to get a sense of the size difference between mine and the new model.

[Bagman]

Originally Posted by jlovda

Beautiful shot!!



I have a question. I own a Pepsi 1675 from 1974. How does the size of my watch compare with your older Pepsi? I'm lusting over the new model and want to get a sense of the size difference between mine and the new model.

Mine probably wears larger. I think they’re both 40mm watches.



Richard B.
#16013 datejust, #216580 Explorer 2 (PVD’d), #16710 Pepsi#218238 yg President, #116610LV Hulk, #126600 Sea dweller, #126710 Pepsi

[Recaro18]

Hands down, 5 digit Pepsi!!




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[eonflux]

Nice pair!

I prefer the 6 digit, except for the colors. Like the Pepsi color of the older model better.

On the 6 digit, I like the ceramic bezel, larger crown, solid links, better clasp, Easylink, new movement.

[Andad]

Originally Posted by Frank McKay

Not a fan of the old tuna can clasps. Modern bracelet/clasps are far more robust and richer feeling. No comparison in that regard.

Hi Frank,

There have been some weld failures on the new GMT clasp.

The old clasp has stood the test of time.

But then the easy link is a nice feature.

I have both and I find my old M Pepsi is more comfortable but I wear the new model more often.

[Gtecko]

5 digit all the way ! 3 different bezel, 2 bracelets (3 if you counts the super jubilee)
cant find anything more versatile !

[swish77]

Recently saw the new version in the flesh for the first time .... the colors just ain't right. Way too muted. And there are many other reasons the 5-digit models are more appealing ... size, feel, design ... aesthetically it wins hands down, especially the 16700. All subjective, of course!

[ROLMARINER]

Originally Posted by swish77

.... the colors just ain't right. Way too muted. All subjective, of course!

Nothing muted about the 6-digit. It has a very dynamic bezel that changes shades based on lighting. Indoors the ceramic goes closer to navy and burgundy which helps it work better with a business suit, but out in the sun it's as bright blue and red and bold as the aluminum version. Subjective, definitely.

[JP.]

Absolutely no contest. Here's my answer.