Price differential for BLNR

[LooseCann0n]

Am looking to purchase a 116710 BLNR and have two options - was wondering if the experienced group can help me decide. The price is the same in both cases.

Option 1
Card from 2013 and recently serviced and case/bracelet refurbished by Rolex with the addition of a new link, glass and crown. Service stickers attached and unworn since so I believe around 2yr warranty.

Option 2
Card from 2017. Therefore also under warranty but marginally less. Great condition so probably had a light polish by the dealer.

The dilemma is, should I go for option 1 as it is in better condition if you discount the age (which is negligible for a watch with an expected lifetime of 100+ years). Or should the lack of price difference lead me towards option 2.

The niggle is the work carried out. Needing a new glass and crown indicates a “bad” accident so what about the refurbishment required on the case/bracelet. If it was say, dropped onto concrete from a height, glass was broken and got into the movement. Also maybe the damage to the case may have required welding etc. Does the RSC do this or do they simply replace the part?

I know that RSC can work wonders but maybe it would be better to get one in original condition..?
Total cost of service was £750 so maybe the damage wasn’t that bad and I am being paranoid..?

What would you do (and why?)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk