Trade value proposition

[Tez777]

Been offered a Heuer CS3111 and an Omega Railmaster, both with full box and papers, for my Rolex OP 116000, blue 3 6 9 "Explorer" dial (also with box and papers).
Just trying to do the maths on them to see if they're in any way equal.
Comments welcome.

[1st amg]

Nope. No thanks

[Kevin of Larchmont]

Neither of those two talk to me. I wouldn't.

[Fleetlord]

Denied

[FL2024]

no chance big regret

[996marty]

That doesn’t sound like a good trade

[rockysw]

nops, doesnt sound like a good trade.

[mike morris]

No, I trade my 116000 blue and still regret .

[JSCP]

why

[brandrea]

Not for me

[VegasBoy]

that's a negative for me

[1259]

I’d be surprised if you get a yes from anyone here

[Stew7]

From a pure value perspective, the numbers sort of make sense if you're working with a dealer. An estimated $3000 USD Heuer + $2500 USD Railmaster = $5500 trade-in value of your OP. They would take the Oyster Perpetual and then sell it for 10-20% more (guessing $6000+) to make their profit. That's kind of the only way the numbers make sense.

If you're dealing with an individual person who is not reselling for profit, it is not really a fair deal in my opinion.

[Al1969]

Pass.

[Jack T]

Yours is a great watch, I had my eye on one of those some years ago, never pulled the trigger, wish I had.
I couldn’t tell you anything about those other two watches, or pricing or whatnot, but personally, I would not give up that OP.

[SLWoodster]

I would just offer for the Heuer CS

[PenDelicate]

Anti-consolidation.

Which would be something like: ephemeralisation. An entirely new watch-trend.

[Mr. Superlative]

Pass.

[OG1982]

Less is more, in this instance.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[toolr]

I really like the 39.2 mm Railmaster, but the 116000 OP is a Go Anywhere Do Anything watch and I wouldn't consider trading it.

[londondude]

I would pass

[Harry-57]

I wouldn't.

Who is offering? If it's a dealer you already know all you need to.

[rmlovett1]

I personally wouldn’t.

[1William]

The numbers may add up on the front end but if you decide to move either of the two watches you acquire you will be out some value. I would not do it as the sum of two does not equal one. Either financially or wear wise for me.