Explorer 114270 VS. OP 36mm 'Explorer dial'

[Watch Explorer]

Hi everyone,

First time poster here and would be grateful for your input.

I have decided I would like to trade (+ cash) my IWC Mark XVI for either a 36mm Explorer 114270 or a new blue OP 36 with the Explorer style dial. I am able to get them at a similar price, possibly a couple hundred USD more for the Explorer depending on condition.

I will treat this watch as my GADA and will rarely be off my wrist apart from a few activities where i'll use a beater. (Although would love to be able to swim with it with confidence).

Here are a few Pro's/info of the 2 models and i'm hopeful you could add some good advice.

Oyster Perpetual:

- Great looking sunburst blue dial
- Wears slightly larger than the Explorer and feels more robust on the wrist due to updated case with wider lugs etc.
- Updated solid feeling bracelet
- Lumed 3-6-9
- Parachrome hairspring so slightly more anti-magnetic?
- The 'OG' Explorer?
- 5 year Rolex warranty

Explorer:

- Great dial also
- A Rolex Sports model
- safety lock clasp
- Lumed second hand
- Holds it value better
- Would get a 6 month warranty from my dealer.

I have included a photo so you can check them out on my wrist side by side.

Thanks all!