New vs used Datejust

[samwellg]

First purchase coming up. I am torn between going with a used datejust between the 80s-90s or going new 2014.

First: the used Rolex I went to see was OK, the dial was very sleek and clean, very much something I am going for. However, the band wasnt something I could settle on. I really want the super jubilee, which I believe didnt get introduced until 2005-6. Price out the door - $3300

Second: Brand new rolex, it has the super jubilee band I want, but the dial is nothing like the old style. It seems a little busy, but it may be something I have to get used to. Price out the door -$7950

Third: This watch is best of both worlds, but the price makes it tough to really decide on. It has the super jubilee and the dial is sleek and clean; not too busy. Price out the door - ~$5000

Heres whats going on. I can go vintage and be satisfied, but with the hollow links, there will be some separation. Obviously too not knowing exactly how this watch has been serviced which does concern me considering I will be spending a few thousand. I want to go new so I have the piece of mind and lately I have been leaning that way completely. But now there is this watch in the middle, but still an older watch.

Pretty much: Is it worth going new and feeling great and just having to get used to the dial. Or spend half the money and not have that experience of a brand new watch. I understand Rolex watches hold value and are amazing pieces new or vintage, but itll be my first watch and a lot of money spent either way (on a watch at least).

Any advice?? Money isnt the issue, its spending wisely.

[HogwldFLTR]

Talk to a trusted seller here on the forum and get the new one for a significant discount. DJs seem to take quite a hit when bought at msrp.

[samwellg]

Thats what I heard, but it isnt something I plan on getting rid of anytime soon. So that hit wont be much considering ill get use out of it.

Who are the sellers you speak of?

[Lgear080]

David, than, Sohail, ocrrolexguy, etc.

Buy whatev you want from them and enjoy the piece at the best price and condition.

[Nycturbovr6]

Call David sw! You'll have it the next day

[Time Exposure]

Given you're interest in keeping the watch, I would go new. But first, are you looking just at dealer stock? Or have you glanced at the Rolex website or a catalog for other dial options? I would spend the money for a new watch only if I love the configuration. I wouldn't settle for something I didn't love, even if it were a "better value."
It's my money, it's my choice! Don't settle on a dial you don't love.

[jshepard]

There are plenty of DJs between 1980 and 2014 that you might like. I'd look around until you find the one you want at the price you believe is fair. Fortunately for you the DJ is a very popular watch and you will be a lot of them in the classifieds on TRF alone, not to mention the other watch forums and ADs who sell preowned. If you don't feel confident in going preowned then buy new. All in all, the most important thing is that you get something you're satisfied with, not something you settled for. Settling for price on something you're not happy with is the opposite of spending wisely.

Look at the who's who section of the forum to see who's been getting good feedback. There's quite a few here.

[samwellg]

Thank you for the responses. I looked up David SW and found the exact watch for about 2k less. Still with the dial that isnt something I absolutely love. Still, this gives me an idea about how this watch will be valued. Its unfortunate I cant get the brand new watch with a brand new sleek dial like I want.

There is a diamond dial that is very sleek, with no lines on it whatsoever, but diamonds are really something im going for on my first everyday watch.

[samwellg]

Originally Posted by Time Exposure

Given you're interest in keeping the watch, I would go new. But first, are you looking just at dealer stock? Or have you glanced at the Rolex website or a catalog for other dial options? I would spend the money for a new watch only if I love the configuration. I wouldn't settle for something I didn't love, even if it were a "better value."
It's my money, it's my choice! Don't settle on a dial you don't love.

Both actually. I looked at what was available, but there was a catalog that still didnt have exactly what I wanted.

[GolfPunk]

I bought a 1972 birth year which I had a full overhaul on by my watchmaker. I'm really pleased with it:

[Invictus Maneo]

I dunno??? Your talking about "settling " for a dial? That doesn't sound good to me. If it were me, I'd keep searching until I found exactly what I was looking for. Believe me, it's out there! Just might take some time to find it.
If you contact one of the trusted sellers here on TRF they could probably source exactly what you're looking for. Plus you'll probably save some $$$ in the process! In any case, good luck!

[autohorology]

Your net loss on any DJII is right around 30% off retail in the best situation the second you walk out with it. My vote, buy new but buy it right.

[tucsonrick]

I recently had DavidSW find exactly the combination (watch, dial, bezel) I wanted for my wife. Took him about 5 days. I've had my first Rolex for over 45 years. Figure out what you want and get that. You'll be happier over the long term.

[red98a4ss]

Mine is for sale check out the FS section to find my ad.

[Perrinyanna]

I suggest go with new. Better clasp, blue parachrom spring, peace of mind, etc.