Issues with Mrbronzo

[eknick]

Original post by mrbronzo selling an AP 15300:

https://www.rolexforums.com/showthread.php?t=543340

We went back and forth several times with some questions regarding the watch and since his profile is thin. I did a google search and found his social media profile and also links to his physical business in NY. That really eased my mind about his authenticity and I was ready to pull the trigger. I was intrigued enough to overlook the first red flag: mrbronzo used different emails for all his previous posts.

The second red flag was when I had questions regarding the service history and the type of buckle of the watch, he sent me 2 pictures of an AP which was from an archived post way back in 2010. (which I didn't know at the time, and later he claim was only because he wanted to show me the type of watch I was buying)

Mrbronzo gave me a bank wire account supposedly belong to his wife. When I sent the wire, I took a screenshot and sent it to him as confirmation. I used JP Morgan Chase online banking for the wire, and when I created his recipient profile I used mrbronzo's name as 'nickname' for the account. This showed up in the confirmation and he was nervous. I explained several times that 'nickname' was only for my end to see and its a function of Chase to notate different recipient account, and the wire was directly to his wife.

Couple of hours went by I found out the wire was denied by his bank to due suspicion of fraud activity. Mrbronzo also sent me an email asking me to talk to his bank, but the phone number of the banker he provided corresponds to a 7Eleven store when I googled it. (third red flag)

At first he claimed it was because his name showed up somewhere in the wire instead of his wife so the bank denied the transaction. I checked the detailed wire transcript and the only name that actually showed up on the wire was his wife's name per mrbronzo's instruction. I also confirmed with Chase that it was impossible that the 'nickname' will be included in the wire. (Chase user knows this)

So I concluded that the only reason mrbronzo's bank denied the wire was because he felt insecure and blocked it himself. I've never heard banks deny incoming wire, only outgoing ones, especially if mrbronzo knows that a wire was coming his way. At this point I've had enough, too many red flags and I've lost the wire transaction fee.

I can't be 100% sure it was a scam setup, but too many redflags. It might be just miscommunication, but for a business owner in the state of NY I expected much better communication to explain all the issues from his side. But so far he hasn't given any real explanations to the red flags I mentioned earlier. TBH it really could be miscommunication, but the risk was too much.

I've attached the email screenshot from mrbronzo using old pictures from the forum.