Offered…

[GMTNYC3790]

Was offered a Rootbeer GMT by my AD.

In order to purchase would have to sell my 2018 Explorer 214270 and a 2023 Omega black Moonphase.

Obviously going to take a loss on both, but would you guys do it? Do you think the TT Rootbeer is worth it?

I personally would be very happy with any GMT so wanted the communities take.

Thanks all.

[JRell]

Here is my very honest opinion. You mentioned any GMT. I really wanted the BLNR but couldn’t wait any longer, so took the root beer. To my eyes, the brown bezel was fantastic at night, going to dinner, it was more burgundy. In the day, sun light, it was a light milky brown. The rest of it, the black dial the TT Rosegold, was amazing. That being said I wanted the BLNR, but took the root beer in the meantime. I ended up trading for the BLNR and could not be happier. You have 2 very safe versatile watches. I rank the BLNR in that category. The root beer is not as flashy as the bluesy, but not as versatile as the BLNR. I personally wouldn’t want the root beer as my only watch.

So if the root beer is your first GMT choice, then yes. If not, no.

[GMTNYC3790]

Thank you for your response! That’s awesome that you got your dream watch. The explorer was my first watch, but since then, I’ve had a few. Bought and sold. Right now my whole collection is the explorer, the Moonphase and a Starbucks sub. If I were to go through with it, it would be the Rootbeer and the Starbucks, which in my opinion is still a great combo. What you said about the colorplay of the Rootbeer is why I was attracted to it. I also tend to wear a lot of Black, army green or browns as style choices

[JRell]

Originally Posted by GMTNYC3790

Thank you for your response! That’s awesome that you got your dream watch. The explorer was my first watch, but since then, I’ve had a few. Bought and sold. Right now my whole collection is the explorer, the Moonphase and a Starbucks sub. If I were to go through with it, it would be the Rootbeer and the Starbucks, which in my opinion is still a great combo. What you said about the colorplay of the Rootbeer is why I was attracted to it. I also tend to wear a lot of Black, army green or browns as style choices

Huge difference, didn’t know you had the 12LV! I also have the 12LV. Yes agree that is a fantastic combo. The 12LV for me is versatile enough, and the rootbeer is a great change up. Now I am at a yes!

[Travis29]

Originally Posted by GMTNYC3790

Thank you for your response! That’s awesome that you got your dream watch. The explorer was my first watch, but since then, I’ve had a few. Bought and sold. Right now my whole collection is the explorer, the Moonphase and a Starbucks sub. If I were to go through with it, it would be the Rootbeer and the Starbucks, which in my opinion is still a great combo. What you said about the colorplay of the Rootbeer is why I was attracted to it. I also tend to wear a lot of Black, army green or browns as style choices

Do it!!!! You’re not the only one, I did some collection housekeeping to grab these two.

[train-time]

I've been in this game for nearly 30 years. Essentially the bug bit me and it's like an addiction.... In a nutshell, it's never worth chasing losses to get the next grail to take the next step in the journey.

If you have to sell something (or a couple of pieces) to take the next step..... then pause and think about it. It may be easier to just pass and come back when you are ready. Just my 2 cents.

[the dark knight]

Originally Posted by train-time

I've been in this game for nearly 30 years. Essentially the bug bit me and it's like an addiction.... In a nutshell, it's never worth chasing losses to get the next grail to take the next step in the journey.

If you have to sell something (or a couple of pieces) to take the next step..... then pause and think about it. It may be easier to just pass and come back when you are ready. Just my 2 cents.

Interesting, because in my 20+ years, I've had exactly the opposite experience. I've never regretted a single watch I've had to sell in order to purchase a watch I wanted more, even incurring losses.

[train-time]

Originally Posted by the dark knight

Interesting, because in my 20+ years, I've had exactly the opposite experience. I've never regretted a single watch I've had to sell in order to purchase a watch I wanted more, even incurring losses.

You gotta do what you gotta do to get what you want.... and a Starbucks and Rootbeer do go together nicely. I know what you are saying and sometimes it best just not to look back and enjoy the ride. But perhaps not too often!

[Hulkhunter]

I would do it. I just got one a few weeks ago after an unexpected call from AD.

I love the GMT range. With you selling those other pieces would it be your only watch?

It’s maybe not as suited in that case. I have other watches so see the rootbeer as my special occasions more dressy watch.

If there was a way you could swing keeping the explorer and the rootbeer that would be a killer combo.
I have a 214270 and it’s great for everyday.

[GMTNYC3790]

If I sold the the explorer and the Moonphase I would be left with the sub LIV Starbucks and the GMT Rootbeer

[fskywalker]

Originally Posted by GMTNYC3790

If I sold the the explorer and the Moonphase I would be left with the sub LIV Starbucks and the GMT Rootbeer

Would do the change towards the Rootbeer


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[Hulkhunter]

Originally Posted by GMTNYC3790

If I sold the the explorer and the Moonphase I would be left with the sub LIV Starbucks and the GMT Rootbeer

Hmm, a great 2 piece as well but both quite flashy.

[JRell]

Originally Posted by Hulkhunter

Hmm, a great 2 piece as well but both quite flashy.

Having had both, still have the LV, I would say the root beer is more towards the flashier side, but not overly flashy and the 12LV is more toward the versatile side, but not overly conservative. I think he can pull it off with the 12LV as his more conservative watch. Now the 11LV, that is a light bulb of flashy!

[Hulkhunter]

Originally Posted by JRell

Having had both, still have the LV, I would say the root beer is more towards the flashier side, but not overly flashy and the 12LV is more toward the versatile side, but not overly conservative. I think he can pull it off with the 12LV as his more conservative watch. Now the 11LV, that is a light bulb of flashy!

I currently own both as well. I just mean none of them are under the radar like a black dial explorer or something.

[amh]

Originally Posted by GMTNYC3790

If I sold the the explorer and the Moonphase I would be left with the sub LIV Starbucks and the GMT Rootbeer

Given that I vote 'yes' on the trade. You're kicking two less desirable pieces out of the collection and gaining a clear upgrade.

In terms of Market value I think this is close to 1:1, surprising AD is even offering this.

[train-time]

Originally Posted by amh

Given that I vote 'yes' on the trade. You're kicking two less desirable pieces out of the collection and gaining a clear upgrade.

In terms of Market value I think this is close to 1:1, surprising AD is even offering this.

I do not believe it's a trade at all. He was just offered the Rootbeer and would have to sell the other pieces and as he says, at a loss.

[Tim Plains]

I would be happy with any GMT II as well, and would do it, but not if it's my only watch.

[TheWatchmen]

I wouldn’t do that trade, but…I’ve owned a couple GMT’s and ended up selling them and even though I was a traveling consultant, I never really needed the bezel function, I also don’t care for two tone watches.

If the Root Beer is what you want then sure, but if the SS GMT is what you’re after then I doubt the root beer will satisfy you.

Your move!

[the dark knight]

Yes, I'd definitely do it. I used to believe I was the only one who thought this way until I heard some fairly prominent watch YT'ers say it as well. The Rolex GMTs kind of stand alone. Among the more popular models, it's the only one that doesn't really have an obvious peer/rival.

Sub has countless rivals, Daytona, Explorer as well. You see countless Sub vs XYZ or Daytona vs XYZ comparisons, you rarely see one for a Rolex GMT. So if you get a chance to get one, I'd pull the trigger on it because I think it's truly a special watch.

[swexlin]

Yes, I would do it. A Rootbeer is on my list at some point as well.

[Carguy87]

I too own a Speedmaster Moonphase and absolutely love it, so I wouldn’t trade mine toward even a BLNR (my #1 wait list piece) let alone for a CHNR. That said, I would trade it and all my other “nice” pieces if I were offered a meteorite GMT from my AD, so if the GMT means that much to you I think you’d be happy with the two pieces you have left, but if the CHNR isn’t your first choice I think you’d be disappointed taking the loss on those two pieces after the honeymoon phase wears off.

Plus you’d only have two Rolex pieces in your collection and nothing else so less versatility there if that’s important to you. I know some are happy just wearing one or two nice watches, for many of the rest of us our collections are only limited by finances / spousal tolerance lol.

[Sandpit]

Sell 2 to get 1? No deal in my opinion.

[MJZRolex]

I wouldn't do it, but then again, I am not a fan of the Rooter.

[CarlOver]

How much loss is something you need to decide on. CHNR a is an excellent color package. Very unique watch for sure and a GMT. I wouldn’t lose money to make the CHNR happen.

[rohada]

What will make you happier: Having a 2018 Explorer 214270 and a 2023 Omega black Moonphase or having a CHNR GMT?

Secondly, is the financial loss a bigger concern than your desire to have any GMT?

If the one GMT is better than two of the other and the financial loss is not important, then you should do it. If the two answers above are in conflict, then you have to determine which criteria should govern your decision. Good luck to you. Glad I'm not having to contemplate this offer.

[JRell]

After saying my post above, the root beer is one sweet watch. You kinda have to!

[train-time]

Originally Posted by JRell

After saying my post above, the root beer is one sweet watch. You kinda have to!

I have to agree with you on this! Initially when the Rootbeer came out I was not too much of a fan of it, but it has grown on me of late. If one is looking for a TT Sport watch then it fits the bill nicely.

[Harry-57]

For me utility comes first. I would find a GMT Master far more useful than a chrono. The TT CHNR is a stunning watch. Visually clever and with a depth and warmth to its lustre. I don't particularly like that Omega either, but you should do as you see fit, not what I see as fit.

[TimeAZ]

Given that the explorer is the perfect watch, I would say a very firm NO.
214270 is a keeper.

[GMTNYC3790]

Love it!